When is it right for a constructor to throw an exception?

by

The constructor’s job is to bring the object into a usable state. There are basically two schools of thought on this.

One group favors two-stage construction. The constructor merely brings the object into a sleeper state in which it refuses to do any work. There’s an additional function that does the actual initialization.

I’ve never understood the reasoning behind this approach. I’m firmly in the group that supports one-stage construction, where the object is fully initialized and usable after construction.

One-stage constructors should throw if they fail to fully initialize the object. If the object cannot be initialized, it must not be allowed to exist, so the constructor must throw.

More Related Contents:

  1. Why not use exceptions as regular flow of control?
  2. When to throw an exception?
  3. Why should I not wrap every block in “try”-“catch”?
  4. Dealing with “java.lang.OutOfMemoryError: PermGen space” error
  5. Better exception for non-exhaustive patterns in case
  6. Can constructors throw exceptions in Java?
  7. Is it really that bad to catch a general exception?
  8. Could not load file or assembly System.Net.Http.Primitives. Located assembly’s manifest definition does not match the assembly reference
  9. Design by contract using assertions or exceptions? [closed]
  10. Throwing exceptions from constructors
  11. Is it good practice to make the constructor throw an exception? [duplicate]
  12. Cause of Servlet’s ‘Response Already Committed’ [duplicate]
  13. Which, and why, do you prefer Exceptions or Return codes?
  14. Who deletes the memory allocated during a “new” operation which has exception in constructor?
  15. try-catch exceptions in Swift [duplicate]
  16. Why not catch general Exceptions
  17. Are exceptions really for exceptional errors? [closed]
  18. simple IPython example raises exception on sys.exit()
  19. Why is exception handling bad? [closed]
  20. How do exceptions in Haskell work?
  21. How do I not log a particular type of Exception in Logback?
  22. What is causing my OLEDbException, IErrorInfo.GetDescription failed with E_FAIL(0x80004005)
  23. Why are Exceptions said to be so bad for Input Validation?
  24. When should I use Debug.Assert()?
  25. Can I get detailed exception stacktrace in PowerShell?
  26. Input string was not in a correct format
  27. Binary Search in Array
  28. Is Sleep() evil?
  29. hasattr() vs try-except block to deal with non-existent attributes
  30. EXC_BAD_INSTRUCTION (code=EXC_I386_INVOP, subcode=0x0) on dispatch_semaphore_dispose

Leave a Comment