Accessing private members [closed]

by

Let’s not consider ethics for a moment. Let’s consider the standard.

What you are proposing to do is nonstandard. See section 9.2, clause 12 of the standard. “The order of allocation of nonstatic members separated by an access-specifier is unspecified.” Therefore, if you have a class with private members, and a struct with no private members, the standard does not guarantee that the members will be in the same order.

Therefore, if your hack works, it works only by accident, that the compiler writers happened to do it that way. There is no guarantee that it will work on another compiler, a later version of the same compiler, or with different class layouts.

Not to mention that, if you don’t have authority to modify the class (say, to provide a simple accessor function), you probably don’t have authority to object if any implementation detail in the class changes. (One of the ideas behind public and private is to distinguish what is promised from what is freely changeable.) Therefore, the layout may change, or the member might come to mean something different, or be removed altogether.

Herb Sutter wrote a Guru of the Week column on this issue.

Oh, as far as the ethics go? If you really, really have to do something like this, and you can’t get out of it, document it very carefully. If your coding standards have some sort of procedure to flag nonstandard behavior, use them. If not, be very careful to note it in a way it won’t be overlooked when something goes wrong.

More Related Contents:

  1. Why can I use auto on a private type?
  2. Can I access private members from outside the class without using friends?
  3. Why do objects of the same class have access to each other’s private data?
  4. “Incomplete type” in class which has a member of the same type of the class itself
  5. With a private modifier, why can the member in other objects be accessed directly?
  6. a way in c++ to hide a specific function
  7. Why does C++ allow private members to be modified using this approach?
  8. How can I count the number of repeated elements/value in map?
  9. How modulus operation works in C++? [closed]
  10. function parameter evaluation order
  11. Declaring pointers; asterisk on the left or right of the space between the type and name? [duplicate]
  12. Why does the C++ STL not provide any “tree” containers?
  13. C++ – enum vs. const vs. #define
  14. Undefined reference to vtable. Trying to compile a Qt project
  15. imread not working in Opencv
  16. OpenCV Error: Assertion failed (size.width>0 && size.height>0) simple code
  17. Calling private method in C++
  18. What is a copy constructor in C++?
  19. Qt: Best practice for a single instance app protection
  20. How to remove all the occurrences of a char in c++ string
  21. Copy map values to vector in STL [duplicate]
  22. Writing utf16 to file in binary mode
  23. Why does the enhanced GCC 6 optimizer break practical C++ code?
  24. undefined reference to `__stack_chk_fail’
  25. Will C++ exceptions safely propagate through C code?
  26. Best way for interprocess communication in C++
  27. std::string in a multi-threaded program
  28. How to write to middle of a file in C++?
  29. c++ work queues with blocking
  30. How do static variables in lambda function objects work?

Leave a Comment