C++ Memory Barriers for Atomics

by

Both MemoryBarrier (MSVC) and _mm_mfence (supported by several compilers) provide a hardware memory fence, which prevents the processor from moving reads and writes across the fence.

The main difference is that MemoryBarrier has platform specific implementations for x86, x64 and IA64, where as _mm_mfence specifically uses the mfence SSE2 instruction, so it’s not always available.

On x86 and x64 MemoryBarrier is implemented with a xchg and lock or respectively, and I have seen some claims that this is faster than mfence. However my own benchmarks show the opposite, so apparently it’s very much dependent on processor model.

Another difference is that mfence can also be used for ordering non-temporal stores/loads (movntq etc).

GCC also has __sync_synchronize which generates a hardware fence.

asm volatile ("" : : : "memory") in GCC and _ReadWriteBarrier in MSVC only provide a compiler level memory fence, preventing the compiler from reordering memory accesses. That means the processor is still free to do reordering.

Compiler fences are generally used in combination with operations that have some kind of implicit hardware fence. E.g. on x86/x64 all stores have a release fence and loads have an acquire fence, so you just need a compiler fence when implementing load-acquire and store-release.

More Related Contents:

  1. How does the Import Library work? Details?
  2. LPCSTR, LPCTSTR and LPTSTR
  3. How to get screenshot of a window as bitmap object in C++?
  4. How to target Windows XP in Microsoft Visual Studio C++ [duplicate]
  5. Difference between ‘strcpy’ and ‘strcpy_s’?
  6. What is the purpose of the _chkstk() function?
  7. Fatal error: “No Target Architecture” in Visual Studio
  8. VC++ fatal error LNK1168: cannot open filename.exe for writing
  9. How do I get at the exception information when using MiniDumpWriteDump out-of-process?
  10. using sendmessage to send wm_close to another process
  11. Possible problems with NOMINMAX on Visual C++
  12. reading an application’s manifest file?
  13. Is there a limit on number of open files in Windows
  14. OpenCV with Network Cameras
  15. Will new return NULL in any case?
  16. When should I use _mm_sfence _mm_lfence and _mm_mfence
  17. Convert CString to const char*
  18. Qt 5.1.1: Application failed to start because platform plugin “windows” is missing
  19. Start Windows Service From Application without Admin right(c++)
  20. How do I input variables using cin without creating a new line?
  21. C++ compiling on Windows and Linux: ifdef switch [duplicate]
  22. How to properly uninitialize OpenSSL
  23. Why does VS not define the alternative tokens for logical operators?
  24. DLL References in Visual C++
  25. Exception Error c0000005 in VC++
  26. Double delete in initializer_list vs 2013
  27. How do YOU reduce compile time, and linking time for Visual C++ projects (native C++)?
  28. How do I clear the console in BOTH Windows and Linux using C++
  29. LNK2038: mismatch detected for ‘RuntimeLibrary’: value ‘MT_StaticRelease’ doesn’t match value ‘MD_DynamicRelease’ in file.obj
  30. Address of function is not actual code address

Leave a Comment