Choosing between MEF and MAF (System.AddIn)

by

I’ve been evaluating these options and here’s the conclusion that I came to.

MAF is a true addon framework. You can separate your addons completely, even running them inside a separate app domain so that if an addon crashes, it won’t take down your application. It also provides a very complete way of decoupling the addons from depending on anything but the contract you give them. In fact, you can versionize your contract adapters to provide backwards compatibility to old addons while you are upgrading the main App. While this sounds great, it comes with a heavy price you have to pay in order to cross appdomains. You pay this price in speed and also in the flexibility of the types that you can send back and forth.

MEF is more like dependency injection with some additional benefits such as discoverability and … (drawing a blank on this one). The degree of isolation that MAF has is not present in MEF. They are two different frameworks for two different things.

More Related Contents:

  1. Looking for a practical approach to sandboxing .NET plugins
  2. Why do I get a warning icon when I add a reference to an MEF plugin project?
  3. Global keyboard capture in C# application
  4. How to track down log4net problems
  5. How to get relative path from absolute path
  6. store image in database or in a system file? [closed]
  7. Why/when should you use nested classes in .net? Or shouldn’t you?
  8. Calling 32bit Code from 64bit Process
  9. ArgumentNullException or NullReferenceException from extension method?
  10. How to make modal dialog in WPF?
  11. Determine file type of an image
  12. How to serialize an object to XML without getting xmlns=”…”?
  13. How do you enable “Enable .NET Framework source stepping”?
  14. WPF Data Binding and Validation Rules Best Practices
  15. Questions every good .NET developer should be able to answer? [closed]
  16. Is Delegate.EndInvoke() really necessary?
  17. Reference Assemblies folder and different assemblies with the same version
  18. Is .NET Remoting really deprecated?
  19. How to get folder path for ClickOnce application
  20. .net ORM Comparison [closed]
  21. How to set .net Framework 4.5 version in IIS 7 application pool
  22. memory allocation of value types and reference types in .net framework
  23. Identifying the client during a .NET remoting invocation
  24. What’s the difference between a dependency property and an attached property in WPF?
  25. Could not load type from assembly error
  26. Entity Framework 4 Single() vs First() vs FirstOrDefault()
  27. Can/Does WPF have multiple GUI threads?
  28. Reminder – \r\n or \n\r?
  29. Remove Highlight Effect from ListViewItem
  30. Why are try blocks expensive?

Leave a Comment