Combining C++ and C – how does #ifdef __cplusplus work?

by

extern "C" doesn’t really change the way that the compiler reads the code. If your code is in a .c file, it will be compiled as C, if it is in a .cpp file, it will be compiled as C++ (unless you do something strange to your configuration).

What extern "C" does is affect linkage. C++ functions, when compiled, have their names mangled — this is what makes overloading possible. The function name gets modified based on the types and number of parameters, so that two functions with the same name will have different symbol names.

Code inside an extern "C" is still C++ code. There are limitations on what you can do in an extern “C” block, but they’re all about linkage. You can’t define any new symbols that can’t be built with C linkage. That means no classes or templates, for example.

extern "C" blocks nest nicely. There’s also extern "C++" if you find yourself hopelessly trapped inside of extern "C" regions, but it isn’t such a good idea from a cleanliness perspective.

Now, specifically regarding your numbered questions:

Regarding #1: __cplusplus will stay defined inside of extern "C" blocks. This doesn’t matter, though, since the blocks should nest neatly.

Regarding #2: __cplusplus will be defined for any compilation unit that is being run through the C++ compiler. Generally, that means .cpp files and any files being included by that .cpp file. The same .h (or .hh or .hpp or what-have-you) could be interpreted as C or C++ at different times, if different compilation units include them. If you want the prototypes in the .h file to refer to C symbol names, then they must have extern "C" when being interpreted as C++, and they should not have extern "C" when being interpreted as C — hence the #ifdef __cplusplus checking.

To answer your question #3: functions without prototypes will have C++ linkage if they are in .cpp files and not inside of an extern "C" block. This is fine, though, because if it has no prototype, it can only be called by other functions in the same file, and then you don’t generally care what the linkage looks like, because you aren’t planning on having that function be called by anything outside the same compilation unit anyway.

For #4, you’ve got it exactly. If you are including a header for code that has C linkage (such as code that was compiled by a C compiler), then you must extern "C" the header — that way you will be able to link with the library. (Otherwise, your linker would be looking for functions with names like _Z1hic when you were looking for void h(int, char)

5: This sort of mixing is a common reason to use extern "C", and I don’t see anything wrong with doing it this way — just make sure you understand what you are doing.

More Related Contents:

  1. Why are preprocessor macros evil and what are the alternatives?
  2. How do I see a C/C++ source file after preprocessing in Visual Studio?
  3. How to call C++ function from C?
  4. Stringification – how does it work?
  5. Why are #ifndef and #define used in C++ header files?
  6. Comma in C/C++ macro
  7. Define preprocessor macro through CMake?
  8. C++ preprocessor #define-ing a keyword. Is it standards conforming?
  9. Call a C function from C++ code
  10. MSVC++ variadic macro expansion
  11. Multi line preprocessor macros
  12. Namespaces in C
  13. Representing big numbers in source code for readability?
  14. C++ preprocessor: avoid code repetition of member variable list
  15. How to make a variadic macro for std::cout?
  16. Can macros be overloaded by number of arguments?
  17. static vs extern “C”/”C++”
  18. When can you omit the file extension in an #include directive?
  19. What’s the difference between the WIN32 and _WIN32 defines in C++
  20. Somehow register my classes in a list
  21. Can I redefine a C++ macro then define it back?
  22. How to test if preprocessor symbol is #define’d but has no value?
  23. Concat two `const char` string literals
  24. How does C++ Preprocessors work?
  25. What is the NDEBUG preprocessor macro used for (on different platforms)?
  26. What does ## in a #define mean?
  27. Is there a way to do a #define inside of another #define?
  28. When to use extern “C” in simple words? [duplicate]
  29. When to use extern “C” in C++? [duplicate]
  30. How do I run the preprocessor on local headers only?

Leave a Comment