Compiler error : reference to call ambiguous

by

Finding the most specific method is defined in a very formal way in the Java Language Specificaion (JLS). I have extracted below the main items that apply while trying to remove the formal formulae as much as possible.

In summary the main items that apply to your questions are:

The third phase (§15.12.2.4) allows overloading to be combined with variable arity methods, boxing, and unboxing.

  • Then JLS 15.12.2.4 basically determines that both method are applicable, because 10 can be converted to both an Integer... or an int.... So far so good. And the paragraph concludes:

The most specific method (§15.12.2.5) is chosen among the applicable variable-arity methods.

  • Which brings us to JLS 15.12.2.5. This paragraph gives the conditions under which an arity method m(a...) is more specific than another arity method m(b...). In your use case with one parameter and no generics, it boils down to:

m(a...) is more specific than m(b...) iif a <: b, where <: means is a subtype of.

It happens that int is not a subtype of Integer and Integer is not a subtype of int.

To use the JLS language, both call methods are therefore maximally specific (no method is more specific than the other). In this case, the same paragraph concludes:

  • If all the maximally specific methods have override-equivalent (§8.4.2) signatures […] => not your case as no generics are involved and Integer and int are different parameters
  • Otherwise, we say that the method invocation is ambiguous, and a compile-time error occurs.

NOTE

If you replaced Integer... by long... for example, you would have int <: long and the most specific method would be call(int...)*.
Similarly, if you replaced int... by Number..., the call(Integer...) method would be the most specific.

*There was actually a bug in JDKs prior to Java 7 that would show an ambiguous call in that situation.

More Related Contents:

  1. In Java, how do I call a base class’s method from the overriding method in a derived class?
  2. How do I put a method as a parameter in a method call? [duplicate]
  3. Java while loop query [closed]
  4. Nested Java methods [closed]
  5. JAVA- JFrame- non static method cannot be referenced from a static context [duplicate]
  6. How do I correctly implement this code segment without getting a logic error? [closed]
  7. Is List a subclass of List? Why are Java generics not implicitly polymorphic?
  8. Cannot refer to a non-final variable inside an inner class defined in a different method
  9. javafx 8 compatibility issues – FXML static fields
  10. No compiler is provided in this environment. Perhaps you are running on a JRE rather than a JDK?
  11. Integer wrapper class and == operator – where is behavior specified? [duplicate]
  12. How to set -source 1.7 in Android Studio and Gradle
  13. Why is my URI not hierarchical? [duplicate]
  14. Is calling static methods via an object “bad form”? Why?
  15. java.lang.VerifyError: Expecting a stackmap frame at branch target JDK 1.7
  16. Does Java support inner / local / sub methods?
  17. In Java, what is the difference between this.method() and method()?
  18. How to quickly determine if a method is overridden in Java
  19. Static Binding and Dynamic Binding
  20. Difference Between Object Type and Reference Type
  21. how to call a java method using a variable name?
  22. Is The Java Tutorials Translucent Window example giving trouble to those playing with jdk7?
  23. How to set IntelliJ IDEA Project SDK
  24. java.security.cert.CertificateException: Certificates does not conform to algorithm constraints
  25. How do Java programs run without defining the main method?
  26. Java getMethod with subclass parameter
  27. How does one use polymorphism instead of instanceof? (And why?)
  28. Why does this generic java method accept two objects of different type?
  29. javafx 8 compatibility issues – FXML static fields or methods
  30. Static method in Java can be accessed using object instance [duplicate]

Leave a Comment