Deflate compression browser compatibility and advantages over GZIP

by

UPDATE: Browsers have been dropping support for raw deflate. zOompf has completed some very thorough research on this very topic here. Unfortunately, it appears that raw deflate is NOT safe to use.

Check http://www.vervestudios.co/projects/compression-tests/results for more results.


Here are the browsers that have been tested:

/*  Browser                       DEFLATE      ZLIB     */
    XP Internet Explorer 6        PASS         FAIL
    XP Internet Explorer 7        PASS         FAIL
    XP Internet Explorer 8        PASS         FAIL
    Vista Internet Explorer 8     PASS         FAIL
    XP Firefox 3.6.*              PASS         PASS
    XP Firefox 3.5.3              PASS         PASS
    XP Firefox 3.0.14             PASS         PASS
    Win 7 Firefox 3.6.*           PASS         PASS
    Vista Firefox 3.6.*           PASS         PASS
    Vista Firefox 3.5.3           PASS         PASS
    XP Safari 3                   PASS         PASS
    XP Safari 4                   PASS         PASS     
    XP Chrome 3.0.195.27          PASS         PASS
    XP Opera 9                    PASS         PASS
    XP Opera 10                   PASS         PASS
    XP Sea Monkey 1.1.8           PASS         PASS
    Android 1.6 Browser (v4)*     N/A          N/A
    OS-X Safari 4                 PASS         PASS
    OS X Chrome 7.0.517.44        PASS         PASS
    OS X Opera 10.63              PASS         PASS
    iPhone 3.1 Safari             PASS         PASS

* Android Sends HTTP request header “Accept-Encoding: gzip”. Deflate is not permitted.

I conclude that we can always send raw DEFLATE (when the HTTP request header “Accept-Encoding” contains “deflate”) and the browser will be able to correctly interpret the encoded data. Can someone prove this wrong?

note: .NET’s native implementation of DEFLATE (System.IO.Compression.DeflateStream) is raw DEFLATE. It also sucks. Please use zlib.net for all of your .NET deflating needs.

More Related Contents:

  1. How are zlib, gzip and zip related? What do they have in common and how are they different?
  2. Why use deflate instead of gzip for text files served by Apache?
  3. Decompress gzip and zlib string in javascript
  4. Compression formats with good support for random access within archives? [closed]
  5. How to find a good/optimal dictionary for zlib ‘setDictionary’ when processing a given set of data?
  6. What do the terms “CPU bound” and “I/O bound” mean?
  7. How do you test running time of VBA code?
  8. How can I decompress a gzip stream with zlib?
  9. How can I Zip and Unzip a string using GZIPOutputStream that is compatible with .Net?
  10. Easy HTTP requests with gzip/deflate compression
  11. What is copy-on-write?
  12. Gzip versus minify
  13. Can compiler optimization introduce bugs?
  14. Why does the Java API use int instead of short or byte?
  15. RDTSCP in NASM always returns the same value (timing a single instruction)
  16. Hyperparameter optimization for Deep Learning Structures using Bayesian Optimization
  17. Does .NET’s HttpWebResponse uncompress automatically GZiped and Deflated responses?
  18. How to read a single file inside a zip archive
  19. How to do batching without UBOs?
  20. How can I get gzip compression in IIS7 working?
  21. Logger slf4j advantages of formatting with {} instead of string concatenation
  22. What branch misprediction does the Branch Target Buffer detect?
  23. Can I efficiently return an object by value in Rust?
  24. Which compression method to use in PHP?
  25. How to check if a file is gzip compressed?
  26. ZLIB Decompression – Client Side
  27. How do I enable gzip compression when using MVC3 on IIS7?
  28. How do I gzip compress a string in Python?
  29. How to Compress/Decompress tar.gz files in java
  30. Why does BCL GZipStream (with StreamReader) not reliably detect Data Errors with CRC32?

Leave a Comment