Difference between mutation, rebinding, copying value, and assignment operator [duplicate]

by

This is covered in detail in a relatively popular SO question, but I’ll try to explain the issue in your particular context.

When your declare your function, the default parameters get evaluated at that moment. It does not refresh every time you call the function.

The reason why your functions behave differently is because you are treating them differently. In f1 you are mutating the object, while in f2 you are creating a new integer object and assigning it into b. You are not modifying b here, you are reassigning it. It is a different object now. In f1, you keep the same object around.

Consider an alternative function:

def f3(a, l= []):
   l = l + [a]
   return l

This behaves like f2 and doesn’t keep appending to the default list. This is because it is creating a new l without ever modifying the object in the default parameter.

Common style in python is to assign the default parameter of None, then assign a new list. This gets around this whole ambiguity.

def f1(a, l = None):
   if l is None:
       l = []

   l.append(a)

   return l

More Related Contents:

  1. In Python, can I specify a function argument’s default in terms of other arguments?
  2. How to pass arguments to a Button command in Tkinter?
  3. Normal arguments vs. keyword arguments
  4. How does collections.defaultdict work?
  5. How do I create a Python function with optional arguments?
  6. Cannot pass an argument to python with “#!/usr/bin/env python”
  7. How can I pass information (a variable) out of a function? How can I use that from outside, e.g. in other functions?
  8. How can I read a function’s signature including default argument values?
  9. Is there a way to change effective process name in Python?
  10. Python argparse: default value or specified value
  11. Can you list the keyword arguments a function receives?
  12. Python passing list as argument
  13. Python constructor and default value [duplicate]
  14. Python Error: “ValueError: need more than 1 value to unpack”
  15. Error – input expected at most 1 argument, got 3
  16. What is a maximum number of arguments in a Python function?
  17. What is the scope of a defaulted parameter in Python?
  18. Modifying function arguments
  19. Passing argument from Parent function to nested function Python
  20. How can I print multiple things (fixed text and/or variable values) on the same line, all at once?
  21. “TypeError: method() takes 1 positional argument but 2 were given” but I did only pass one
  22. “TypeError: method() takes 1 positional argument but 2 were given” but I only passed one
  23. Collections.defaultdict difference with normal dict
  24. How to define default value if empty user input in Python?
  25. Calling superclass constructors in python with different arguments
  26. python – returning a default value
  27. Unpacking arguments: only named arguments may follow *expression
  28. Defining a default argument as a global variable
  29. With “args” vs without “args” to pass arguments to a thread in Python
  30. How can the built-in range function take a single argument or three?

Leave a Comment