Error: lvalue required in this simple C code? (Ternary with assignment?)

by

Actually, in C, this code 

(a>b)?b=a:b=b;

is parsed by many compilers as

((a>b)?b=a:b)=b;

which is an error, as the expression ((a>b)?b=a:b) evaluates to an rvalue which you try to assign with b which results in an error. Trying to assign an rvalue is an error. If it is not parsed that way, then its simply a syntax error. But a C compiler is NOT allowed to parse it as:

((a>b)?b=a:(b=b)); //not allowed to parse by C language

Because the grammar of C does not allow a compiler to parse the code as above.

But what you’ve written (the original code) is correct as C++.

Here the grammars of C and C++ differ a lot. And because of that difference you see both languages treat the expression differently. That is, the conditional expression in C++ is different from the conditional expression in C .

Wikipedia has very good and correct explanation for this:

The binding of operators in C and C++
is specified (in the corresponding
Standards) by a factored language
grammar, rather than a precedence
table. This creates some subtle
conflicts. For example, in C, the
syntax for a conditional expression
is:

logical-OR-expression ? expression :
conditional-expression

while in C++ it is:

logical-OR-expression ? expression :
assignment-expression

Hence, the expression:

e = a < d ? a++ : a = d

is parsed differently in the two
languages. In C, this expression is a
syntax error, but many compilers parse
it as:

e = ((a < d ? a++ : a) = d)

which is a semantic error, since the
result of the conditional-expression
(which might be a++) is not an lvalue.
In C++, it is parsed as:

e = (a < d ? a++ : (a = d))

which is a valid expression.

More Related Contents:

  1. ?: ternary conditional operator behaviour when leaving one expression empty
  2. The ternary (conditional) operator in C
  3. Why is the conditional operator right associative?
  4. Errors using ternary operator in c
  5. Type result with conditional operator in C#
  6. Is this ternary conditional ?: correct (Objective) C syntax?
  7. Explanation of output of this C code
  8. How does this foo function works?
  9. code ran into segmentation fault error.how to fix? [closed]
  10. Splitting a string into words
  11. Concept of void pointer in C programming
  12. What does fflush(stdin) do in C programing? [duplicate]
  13. Operator overloading in C
  14. Why am I getting a gcc “undefined reference” error trying to create shared objects?
  15. Square of a number being defined using #define
  16. How to use redirection in C for file input
  17. Algorithm to rotate an image 90 degrees in place? (No extra memory)
  18. How do I run a C program from VIM?
  19. What are the implications of the linux __user macro?
  20. Sequence points and side effects in C
  21. How to include a dynamic array INSIDE a struct in C?
  22. What is the correct printf specifier for printing pid_t
  23. Why use the Bitwise-Shift operator for values in a C enum definition?
  24. Open directory using C
  25. AES (aes-cbc-128, aes-cbc-192, aes-cbc-256) encryption/decryption with openssl C
  26. Use a dope vector to access arbitrary axial slices of a multidimensional array?
  27. Exceeding array bound in C — Why does this NOT crash?
  28. Printing pointers in C
  29. How to compute 2⁶⁴/n in C?
  30. Where do malloc() and free() store allocated sizes and addresses?

Leave a Comment