FFmpeg: How to split video efficiently?

by

The ffmpeg wiki links back to this page in reference to “How to split video efficiently”. I’m not convinced this page answers that question, so I did as @AlcubierreDrive suggested…

echo "Two commands" 
time ffmpeg -v quiet -y -i input.ts -vcodec copy -acodec copy -ss 00:00:00 -t 00:30:00 -sn test1.mkv
time ffmpeg -v quiet -y -i input.ts -vcodec copy -acodec copy -ss 00:30:00 -t 01:00:00 -sn test2.mkv
echo "One command" 
time ffmpeg -v quiet -y -i input.ts -vcodec copy -acodec copy -ss 00:00:00 -t 00:30:00 \
  -sn test3.mkv -vcodec copy -acodec copy -ss 00:30:00 -t 01:00:00 -sn test4.mkv

Which outputs…

Two commands
real    0m16.201s
user    0m1.830s
sys 0m1.301s

real    0m43.621s
user    0m4.943s
sys 0m2.908s

One command
real    0m59.410s
user    0m5.577s
sys 0m3.939s

I tested a SD & HD file, after a few runs & a little maths.

Two commands SD 0m53.94 #2 wins  
One command  SD 0m49.63  

Two commands SD 0m55.00  
One command  SD 0m52.26 #1 wins 

Two commands SD 0m58.60 #2 wins  
One command  SD 0m58.61 

Two commands SD 0m54.60  
One command  SD 0m50.51 #1 wins 

Two commands SD 0m53.94  
One command  SD 0m49.63 #1 wins  

Two commands SD 0m55.00  
One command  SD 0m52.26 #1 wins 

Two commands SD 0m58.71  
One command  SD 0m58.61 #1 wins

Two commands SD 0m54.63  
One command  SD 0m50.51 #1 wins  

Two commands SD 1m6.67s #2 wins  
One command  SD 1m20.18  

Two commands SD 1m7.67  
One command  SD 1m6.72 #1 wins

Two commands SD 1m4.92  
One command  SD 1m2.24 #1 wins

Two commands SD 1m1.73  
One command  SD 0m59.72 #1 wins

Two commands HD 4m23.20  
One command  HD 3m40.02 #1 wins

Two commands SD 1m1.30  
One command  SD 0m59.59 #1 wins  

Two commands HD 3m47.89  
One command  HD 3m29.59 #1 wins  

Two commands SD 0m59.82  
One command  SD 0m59.41 #1 wins  

Two commands HD 3m51.18  
One command  HD 3m30.79 #1 wins

SD file = 1.35GB DVB transport stream
HD file = 3.14GB DVB transport stream

Conclusion

The single command is better if you are handling HD, it agrees with the manuals comments on using -ss after the input file to do a ‘slow seek’. SD files have a negligible difference.

The two command version should be quicker by adding another -ss before the input file for the a ‘fast seek’ followed by the more accurate slow seek.

More Related Contents:

  1. How to concatenate two MP4 files using FFmpeg?
  2. How do you convert an entire directory with ffmpeg?
  3. Vertically or horizontally stack (mosaic) several videos using ffmpeg? [closed]
  4. FFMPEG (libx264) “height not divisible by 2”
  5. Rotating videos with FFmpeg
  6. How to output fragmented mp4 with ffmpeg?
  7. Text on video ffmpeg
  8. Post processing in ffmpeg to move ‘moov atom’ in MP4 files (qt-faststart)
  9. How can I extract audio from video with ffmpeg?
  10. Can ffmpeg show a progress bar?
  11. How to install and run phpize
  12. Using ffmpeg to change framerate
  13. Remove sequentially duplicate frames when using FFmpeg
  14. How to resize a picture using ffmpeg’s sws_scale()?
  15. How to convert RGB from YUV420p for ffmpeg encoder?
  16. adding silent audio in ffmpeg
  17. Is there a way to use ffmpeg to determine the encoding of a file before transcoding?
  18. Use ffmpeg to add text subtitles [closed]
  19. Live streaming dash content using mp4box
  20. How to control key-frame generation of ffmpeg?
  21. How to add album art with ffmpeg?
  22. Image sequence to video quality [closed]
  23. Getting green screen in ffplay: Streaming desktop (DirectX surface) as H264 video over RTP stream using Live555
  24. FFMPEG: get last 10 seconds [closed]
  25. ffmpeg for a android (using tutorial: “ffmpeg and Android.mk”)
  26. Best approach to real time http streaming to HTML5 video client [closed]
  27. How can I extract a good quality JPEG image from a video file with ffmpeg?
  28. using FFMPEG with silencedetect to remove audio silence
  29. problem compiling ffmpeg for iFrameExtractor
  30. Use FFmpeg in Visual Studio

Leave a Comment