How does str.startswith really work?

by

There is technically no reason to accept other sequence types, no. The source code roughly does this:

if isinstance(prefix, tuple):
    for substring in prefix:
        if not isinstance(substring, str):
            raise TypeError(...)
        return tailmatch(...)
elif not isinstance(prefix, str):
    raise TypeError(...)
return tailmatch(...)

(where tailmatch(...) does the actual matching work).

So yes, any iterable would do for that for loop. But, all the other string test APIs (as well as isinstance() and issubclass()) that take multiple values also only accept tuples, and this tells you as a user of the API that it is safe to assume that the value won’t be mutated. You can’t mutate a tuple but the method could in theory mutate the list.

Also note that you usually test for a fixed number of prefixes or suffixes or classes (in the case of isinstance() and issubclass()); the implementation is not suited for a large number of elements. A tuple implies that you have a limited number of elements, while lists can be arbitrarily large.

Next, if any iterable or sequence type would be acceptable, then that would include strings; a single string is also a sequence. Should then a single string argument be treated as separate characters, or as a single prefix?

So in other words, it’s a limitation to self-document that the sequence won’t be mutated, is consistent with other APIs, it carries an implication of a limited number of items to test against, and removes ambiguity as to how a single string argument should be treated.

Note that this was brought up before on the Python Ideas list; see this thread; Guido van Rossum’s main argument there is that you either special case for single strings or for only accepting a tuple. He picked the latter and doesn’t see a need to change this.

More Related Contents:

  1. Unable to use convert strings into integers for a for loop
  2. User input integer list [duplicate]
  3. how to unpack a tuple in this form (‘abc’, [20, 20])? [closed]
  4. Convert a columns of string to list in pandas
  5. How to sort a list of strings in reverse order without using reverse=True parameter?
  6. Deleting consonants from a string in Python
  7. Concatenate elements of a tuple in a list in python [duplicate]
  8. Converting string to tuple without splitting characters
  9. Printing the number from a list and its square on the same line in python3 [closed]
  10. Python3 – create global variable(list) from function
  11. Count frequency of words in a list and sort by frequency
  12. Calling filter returns [duplicate]
  13. Pandas DataFrame stored list as string: How to convert back to list
  14. Check if string ends with one of the strings from a list
  15. a mutable type inside an immutable container
  16. Converting a list of tuples into a dict
  17. How does the max() function work on list of strings in python?
  18. str.startswith with a list of strings to test for
  19. Removing control characters from a string in python
  20. How to split strings inside a list by whitespace characters
  21. Find an element in a list of tuples
  22. How to convert list of tuples to multiple lists?
  23. Python range() and zip() object type
  24. What does *tuple and **dict mean in Python? [duplicate]
  25. Python: find closest string (from a list) to another string
  26. “TypeError: a bytes-like object is required, not ‘str'” when handling file content in Python 3
  27. Sort a list of tuples depending on two elements [duplicate]
  28. “TypeError: ‘type’ object is not subscriptable” in a function signature
  29. Finding the position of a word in a string
  30. Convert bytes to a string in python 3

Leave a Comment