In WinForms, why can’t you update UI controls from other threads?

by

I think this is a brilliant question –
and I think there is need of a better
answer.

Surely the only reason is that there
is something in a framework somewhere
that isn’t very thread-safe.

That “something” is almost every single instance member on every single control in System.Windows.Forms.

The MSDN documentation for many controls in System.Windows.Forms, if not all of them, say “Any public static (Shared in Visual Basic) members of this type are thread safe. Any instance members are not guaranteed to be thread safe.”

This means that instance members such as TextBox.Text {get; set;} are not reentrant.

Making each of those instance members thread safe could introduce a lot of overhead that most applications do not need. Instead the designers of the .Net framework decided, and I think correctly, that the burden of synchronizing access to forms controls from multiple threads should be put on the programmer.

[Edit]

Although this question only asks “why” here is a link to an article that explains “how”:

How to: Make Thread-Safe Calls to Windows Forms Controls on MSDN

http://msdn.microsoft.com/en-us/library/ms171728.aspx

More Related Contents:

  1. Invoke or BeginInvoke cannot be called on a control until the window handle has been created
  2. System.Windows.Threading.Dispatcher and WinForms?
  3. Cross-thread operation not valid: Control accessed from a thread other than the thread it was created on
  4. How to stop BackgroundWorker on Form’s Closing event?
  5. Automating the InvokeRequired code pattern
  6. Question about terminating a thread cleanly in .NET
  7. BackgroundWorker vs background Thread
  8. How do I update the GUI from another thread?
  9. Cross-thread operation not valid [duplicate]
  10. Why the form load can’t catch exception?
  11. Writing to a TextBox from another thread? [duplicate]
  12. UI Design Pattern for Windows Forms (like MVVM for WPF)
  13. How do I turn off Compatibility View on the IE WebBrowserControl in a WinForms app?
  14. Formatting text in WinForm Label
  15. How to update textbox on GUI from another thread [duplicate]
  16. How would you implement MVC in a Windows Forms application?
  17. How to disable a WinForms TreeView node checkbox?
  18. PowerShell: Job Event Action with Form not executed
  19. Windows forms – add data to list view on button click [duplicate]
  20. How to draw custom button in Window Titlebar with Windows Forms?
  21. Stop comboBox’s selectedIndexChanged event from firing when the form loads
  22. Spawn a new thread to open a new window and close it from a different thread
  23. Max Char in TextBox C#?
  24. Getting Cross-thread operation not valid [duplicate]
  25. C# Windows Forms Application – Updating GUI from another thread AND class?
  26. Ribbon UI Control for WinForms
  27. Adding button into a Listview in WinForms
  28. How to access a WinForms control from another thread i.e. synchronize with the GUI thread?
  29. Populating a DataGridView with Text and ProgressBars
  30. Draw on a form by a separate thread

Leave a Comment