Inheriting from Frame or not in a Tkinter application

by

The option I prefer* is to inherit from the class Tk. I think it is the more reasonable choice since the window is, in effect, your application. Inheriting from Frame doesn’t make any more sense to me then inheriting from Button or Canvas or Label. Since you can only have a single root, it makes sense that that is what you inherit from.

I also think it makes the code more readable if you do the import as import Tkinter as tk rather than from Tkinter import *. All of your calls then explicitly mention the tk module. I don’t recommend this for all modules, but to me it makes sense with Tkinter.

For example:

import Tkinter as tk

class SampleApp(tk.Tk):
    def __init__(self, *args, **kwargs):
        tk.Tk.__init__(self, *args, **kwargs)
        self.label = tk.Label(text="Hello, world")
        self.label.pack(padx=10, pady=10)

app = SampleApp()
app.mainloop()

* Note: since originally writing this answer I have changed my position. I now prefer to inherit from Frame rather than Tk. There’s no real advantage one way or the other, it’s more of a philosophical choice than anything else. Regardless, I believe that whether you inherit from Frame or Tk, I think either choice is better than the first example in the code that inherits from nothing.

The one slight advantage inheriting from Frame has over Tk is in the case where you want your application to support multiple identical windows. In that case, inheriting from Frame lets you create the first window as a child of root, and additional windows as children of instances of Toplevel. However, I’ve seen very few programs that ever have a need to do this.

For more information about how I think Tkinter programs should be structured, see my answer to the question Python Tkinter program structure.

More Related Contents:

  1. Python collapsible sidebar on tkinter [closed]
  2. Tkinter Placing And Deleting A Label
  3. Interactively validating Entry widget content in tkinter
  4. In Tkinter is there any way to make a widget invisible?
  5. How to stop Tkinter Frame from shrinking to fit its contents?
  6. Update Tkinter Label from variable
  7. Play Animations in GIF with Tkinter [duplicate]
  8. Why is Tkinter widget stored as None? (AttributeError: ‘NoneType’ object …)(TypeError: ‘NoneType’ object …) [duplicate]
  9. simple animation using tkinter
  10. How to add a question mark [?] button on the top of a tkinter window
  11. filedialog, tkinter and opening files
  12. Tkinter canvas zoom + move/pan
  13. Getting Checkbutton state
  14. Removing minimize/maximize buttons in Tkinter
  15. How do I stop tkinter after function?
  16. Tkinter have code for pages in separate files
  17. How do I create child windows with Python tkinter?
  18. Python tkinter text modified callback
  19. Tkinter Frame Resize
  20. How to do a screenshot of a tkinter application?
  21. How to create a modal dialog in tkinter?
  22. python – While Loop causes entire program to crash in Tkinter
  23. Switching between frames in tkinter menu
  24. How to change a widget’s font style without knowing the widget’s font family/size?
  25. How to install python application with tkcalendar module by pyinstaller?
  26. Tkinter Show splash screen and hide main screen until __init__ has finished
  27. Correctly extend a tkinter widget using inheritance
  28. NoneType Error self.widget.insert
  29. How do I run unittest on a Tkinter app?
  30. How do I compile my Python 3 app to an .exe? [closed]

Leave a Comment