Is C# 6 ?. (Elvis op) thread safe? If so, how?

by

I want to clarify BJ Myers’s (correct) answer.

In C# an event can be thought of as a field of delegate type — just as a property can be thought of as a field of the property type — and the value of that “field” can be null. If you are in the unfortunate situation of having an event handler being modified on one thread while another thread is attempting to invoke it, you can get into the situation where:

if (this.SomeEvent != null) 
    this.SomeEvent( ... );

is not threadsafe. The value could be mutated so that it is non-null before the check, null after the check, and the program crashes.

The usual way to make this “threadsafe”, and I use the term advisedly, is to copy the value to a local and then test the local for null. This has the benefit of not crashing with a null dereference. However, the clever developer will note that there is still a race! The sequence can be

  • Non-null event handler cached on thread A
  • Event handler set to null on thread B
  • State needed by event handler is destroyed on thread B
  • Event handler runs on thread A and dies horribly

So in that sense this pattern is not “thread safe”. If you are in this unfortunate position you are responsible for ensuring that the appropriate threading logic is implemented so that this cannot happen. You can do that however you want. If you want the (questionable) benefits of being able to call an event handler on one thread while mutating the event on another thread, then you’ve got to pay either to make it safe, or deal with race condition bugs.

I personally would avoid this situation like the plague, but I’m not smart enough to write correct multithreaded code.

Now, as for the actual question:

some_expression ?. ToString();

is the same as

temp = some_expression
temp == null ? null : temp.ToString()

Is the latter code “threadsafe” in your opinion?

More Related Contents:

  1. What does the => operator mean in a property?
  2. What does question mark and dot operator ?. mean in C# 6.0?
  3. Does C# 6.0 work for .NET 4.0?
  4. How to use the ternary operator inside an interpolated string?
  5. C# elegant way to check if a property’s property is null
  6. C# 6.0 Features Not Working with Visual Studio 2015
  7. What is the difference between getter-only auto properties and expression body properties?
  8. What is the purpose of nameof?
  9. How do I use the C#6 “Using static” feature?
  10. Is nameof() evaluated at compile-time?
  11. Delegate caching behavior changes in Roslyn
  12. Await in catch block
  13. Expression-bodied function members efficiency and performance in C# 6.0
  14. Automated property with getter only, can be set, why?
  15. C#6.0 string interpolation localization
  16. How to implement INotifyPropertyChanged in C# 6.0?
  17. UnassignedReferenceException even though using the null-conditional operator
  18. What does the => operator mean in a property or method?
  19. How to use C# 6 with Web Site project type?
  20. Long string interpolation lines in C#6
  21. Lambda for getter and setter of property
  22. How to use verbatim strings with interpolation?
  23. What is the meaning of the planned “private protected” C# access modifier?
  24. How to upgrade msbuild to C# 6?
  25. What benefits does dictionary initializers add over collection initializers?
  26. What is the final format for string interpolation in VS 2015?
  27. C# 6.0 Null Propagation Operator & Property Assignment
  28. String interpolation in a Razor view?
  29. Error CS1056: Unexpected character ‘$’ running the msbuild on a tfs continuous integration process
  30. C# 6.0 Support in Visual Studio 2012

Leave a Comment