Is changing a pointer considered an atomic action in C?

by

As others have mentioned, there is nothing in the C language that guarantees this, and it is dependent on your platform.

On most contemporary desktop platforms, the read/write to a word-sized, aligned location will be atomic. But that really doesn’t solve your problem, due to processor and compiler re-ordering of reads and writes.

For example, the following code is broken:

Thread A:

DoWork();
workDone = 1;

Thread B:

while(workDone != 0);

ReceiveResultsOfWork();

Although the write to workDone is atomic, on many systems there is no guarantee by the processor that the write to workDone will be visible to other processors before writes done via DoWork() are visible. The compiler may also be free to re-order the write to workDone to before the call to DoWork(). In both cases, ReceiveResultsOfWork() might start working on incomplete data.

Depending on your platform, you may need to insert memory fences and so on to ensure proper ordering. This can be very tricky to get right.

Or just use locks. Much simpler, much easier to verify as correct, and in most cases more than performant enough.

More Related Contents:

  1. WaitForSingleObject and WaitForMultipleObjects equivalent in Linux?
  2. Best way to multi-thread? [closed]
  3. Please explain the following parallel code template
  4. Undefined reference to pthread_create in Linux
  5. Is malloc thread-safe?
  6. Are C++ Reads and Writes of an int Atomic?
  7. Mutex example / tutorial? [closed]
  8. When the main thread exits, do other threads also exit?
  9. How to share semaphores between processes using shared memory
  10. How to protect resources that may be used in a multi-threaded or async environment?
  11. Kill Thread in Pthread Library
  12. Is it possible to determine the thread holding a mutex?
  13. Can I get Unix’s pthread.h to compile in Windows?
  14. What are the differences between various threading synchronization options in C#?
  15. C11 GCC threads.h not found?
  16. Monitor vs Mutex in c# [duplicate]
  17. Pthread Run a thread right after it’s creation
  18. Do threads have a distinct heap?
  19. Lock (Monitor) internal implementation in .NET
  20. How do you query a pthread to see if it is still running?
  21. Memory order consume usage in C11
  22. Does any C library implement C11 threads for GNU/Linux?
  23. SynchronizationLockException on Monitor.Exit when using await
  24. How to make main thread wait for all child threads finish?
  25. Linux/POSIX equivalent for Win32’s CreateEvent, SetEvent, WaitForSingleObject
  26. CPU cache inhibition
  27. Which thread handles the signal?
  28. Unexpected output in a multithreaded program
  29. Can multithreading be implemented on a single processor system?
  30. How to get the number of CPUs in Linux using C?

Leave a Comment