Is it good to set the max and min JVM heap size the same?

by

Update: This answer was originally written in 2014 and is obsolete.

Peter ‘s answer is correct in that -Xms is allocated at startup and it will grow up to -Xmx (max heap size) but it’s a little misleading in how he has worded his answer. (Sorry Peter I know you know this stuff cold).

Setting ms == mx effectively turns off this behavior. While this used to be a good idea in older JVMs, it is no longer the case. Growing and shrinking the heap allows the JVM to adapt to increases in pressure on memory yet reduce pause time by shrinking the heap when memory pressure is reduced. Sometimes this behavior doesn’t give you the performance benefits you’d expect and in those cases it’s best to set mx == ms.
OOME is thrown when heap is more than 98% of time is spent collecting and the collections cannot recover more than 2% of that. If you are not at max heaps size then the JVM will simply grow so that you’re beyond that boundaries. You cannot have an OutOfMemoryError on startup unless your heap hits the max heap size and meets the other conditions that define an OutOfMemoryError.

For the comments that have come in since I posted. I don’t know what the JMonitor blog entry is showing but this is from the PSYoung collector.

size_t desired_size = MAX2(MIN2(eden_plus_survivors, gen_size_limit()),
                           min_gen_size());

I could do more digging about but I’d bet I’d find code that serves the same purpose in the ParNew and PSOldGen and CMS Tenured implementations. In fact it’s unlikely that CMS would be able to return memory unless there has been a Concurrent Mode Failure. In the case of a CMF the serial collector will run and that should include a compaction after which top of heap would most likely be clean and therefore eligible to be deallocated.

More Related Contents:

  1. How can I tell if I’m running in 64-bit JVM or 32-bit JVM (from within a program)?
  2. How to see JIT-compiled code in JVM?
  3. What is the exact meaning of static fields in Java?
  4. Running jmap getting Unable to open socket file
  5. How to fix java.lang.UnsupportedClassVersionError: Unsupported major.minor version
  6. Jvm takes a long time to resolve ip-address for localhost
  7. What is in Java object header?
  8. Increasing the JVM maximum heap size for memory intensive applications
  9. Is there a way to get a reference address? [duplicate]
  10. How do I find out what keystore my JVM is using?
  11. Error launching Android Studio: Failed to create JVM: error code-6
  12. String s = new String(“xyz”). How many objects has been made after this line of code execute?
  13. What is the largest possible heap size with a 64-bit JVM?
  14. Java VM: reproducible SIGSEGV on both 1.6.0_17 and 1.6.0_18, how to report?
  15. Cannot load 64-bit SWT libraries on 32-bit JVM ( replacing SWT file )
  16. Determining location of JVM executable during runtime
  17. Cannot assign requested address using ServerSocket.socketBind
  18. What java.security.egd option is for?
  19. What is the default maximum heap size for Sun’s JVM from Java SE 6?
  20. Is there a simple way of obtaining all object instances of a specific class in Java
  21. Tail Call Optimisation in Java
  22. Duplicated Java runtime options : what is the order of preference?
  23. JVM memory usage out of control
  24. How JVM stack, heap and threads are mapped to physical memory or operation system
  25. Specifying JVM arguments when calling a jar file?
  26. how to increase java heap memory permanently?
  27. How can I add a Javaagent to a JVM without stopping the JVM?
  28. Java Memory explained (SUN JVM)
  29. how to choose the jvm heap size?
  30. Trick behind JVM’s compressed Oops

Leave a Comment