Is JavaScript object-oriented?

by

IMO (and it is only an opinion) the key characteristic of an object orientated language would be that it would support polymorphism. Pretty much all dynamic languages do that.

The next characteristic would be encapsulation and that is pretty easy to do in Javascript also.

However in the minds of many it is inheritance (specifically implementation inheritance) which would tip the balance as to whether a language qualifies to be called object oriented.

Javascript does provide a fairly easy means to inherit implementation via prototyping but this is at the expense of encapsulation.

So if your criteria for object orientation is the classic threesome of polymorphism, encapsulation and inheritance then Javascript doesn’t pass.

Edit: The supplementary question is raised “how does prototypal inheritance sacrifice encapsulation?” Consider this example of a non-prototypal approach:-

function MyClass() {
    var _value = 1;
    this.getValue = function() { return _value; }
}

The _value attribute is encapsulated, it cannot be modified directly by external code. We might add a mutator to the class to modify it in a way entirely controlled by code that is part of the class. Now consider a prototypal approach to the same class:-

function MyClass() {
  var _value = 1;
}
MyClass.prototype.getValue = function() { return _value; }

Well this is broken. Since the function assigned to getValue is no longer in scope with _value it can’t access it. We would need to promote _value to an attribute of this but that would make it accessable outside of the control of code written for the class, hence encapsulation is broken.

Despite this my vote still remains that Javascript is object oriented. Why? Because given an OOD I can implement it in Javascript.

More Related Contents:

  1. Advantages of using prototype, vs defining methods straight in the constructor? [duplicate]
  2. How to get a JavaScript object’s class?
  3. The value of “this” within the handler using addEventListener
  4. Anonymous class instance —- is it a bad idea?
  5. Class vs. static method in JavaScript
  6. JavaScript: Class.method vs. Class.prototype.method
  7. Understanding prototypal inheritance in JavaScript
  8. Adding custom properties to a function
  9. Get functions (methods) of a class [duplicate]
  10. Difference of the value, prototype and property
  11. JavaScript private methods
  12. What does it mean that Javascript is a prototype based language?
  13. Access parent’s parent from javascript object
  14. Properties of Javascript function objects
  15. setTimeout() inside JavaScript Class using “this”
  16. How to call a parent method from child class in javascript?
  17. How to dynamically set a function/object name in Javascript as it is displayed in Chrome
  18. Why are my JavaScript object properties being overwritten by other instances?
  19. Object oriented javascript with prototypes vs closures
  20. Javascript OOP best practices? [closed]
  21. Objects don’t inherit prototyped functions
  22. ES6 – Call static method within a class
  23. Does JavaScript have classes?
  24. Preserve ‘this’ reference in javascript prototype event handler [duplicate]
  25. clearRect not working
  26. JavaScript override methods
  27. Does ECMAScript 6 have a convention for abstract classes? [duplicate]
  28. Why is it impossible to change constructor function from prototype?
  29. Duck Typing in Javascript
  30. Why aren’t methods of an object created with class bound to it in ES6?

Leave a Comment