Is System.nanoTime() completely useless?

by

This answer was written in 2011 from the point of view of what the Sun JDK of the time running on operating systems of the time actually did. That was a long time ago! leventov’s answer offers a more up-to-date perspective.

That post is wrong, and nanoTime is safe. There’s a comment on the post which links to a blog post by David Holmes, a realtime and concurrency guy at Sun. It says:

System.nanoTime() is implemented using the QueryPerformanceCounter/QueryPerformanceFrequency API […] The default mechanism used by QPC is determined by the Hardware Abstraction layer(HAL) […] This default changes not only across hardware but also across OS versions. For example Windows XP Service Pack 2 changed things to use the power management timer (PMTimer) rather than the processor timestamp-counter (TSC) due to problems with the TSC not being synchronized on different processors in SMP systems, and due the fact its frequency can vary (and hence its relationship to elapsed time) based on power-management settings.

So, on Windows, this was a problem up until WinXP SP2, but it isn’t now.

I can’t find a part II (or more) that talks about other platforms, but that article does include a remark that Linux has encountered and solved the same problem in the same way, with a link to the FAQ for clock_gettime(CLOCK_REALTIME), which says:

  1. Is clock_gettime(CLOCK_REALTIME) consistent across all processors/cores? (Does arch matter? e.g. ppc, arm, x86, amd64, sparc).

It should or it’s considered buggy.

However, on x86/x86_64, it is possible to see unsynced or variable freq TSCs cause time inconsistencies. 2.4 kernels really had no protection against this, and early 2.6 kernels didn’t do too well here either. As of 2.6.18 and up the logic for detecting this is better and we’ll usually fall back to a safe clocksource.

ppc always has a synced timebase, so that shouldn’t be an issue.

So, if Holmes’s link can be read as implying that nanoTime calls clock_gettime(CLOCK_REALTIME), then it’s safe-ish as of kernel 2.6.18 on x86, and always on PowerPC (because IBM and Motorola, unlike Intel, actually know how to design microprocessors).

There’s no mention of SPARC or Solaris, sadly. And of course, we have no idea what IBM JVMs do. But Sun JVMs on modern Windows and Linux get this right.

EDIT: This answer is based on the sources it cites. But i still worry that it might actually be completely wrong. Some more up-to-date information would be really valuable. I just came across to a link to a four year newer article about Linux’s clocks which could be useful.

More Related Contents:

  1. Java 8 Instant.now() with nanosecond resolution?
  2. Precision vs. accuracy of System.nanoTime()
  3. How to suspend a java thread for a small period of time, like 100 nanoseconds?
  4. Java while loop query [closed]
  5. Why is char[] preferred over String for passwords?
  6. Named parameters in JDBC [duplicate]
  7. Firestore – how to structure a feed and follow system
  8. Java 7 underscore in numeric literals
  9. Adding Java Annotations at Runtime
  10. How to create my own Appender in log4j?
  11. How to read all of Inputstream in Server Socket JAVA
  12. How to unmap a file from memory mapped using FileChannel in java?
  13. String contains – ignore case [duplicate]
  14. final array in Java
  15. Volatile variable in Java
  16. Create PDU for Android that works with SmsMessage.createFromPdu() (GSM 3gpp)
  17. Stax XMLStreamReader check for the next event without moving ahead
  18. when to use toString() method
  19. How to save state when extending UIComponentBase
  20. How do I put a Java app in the system tray?
  21. Mockito – NullpointerException when stubbing Method
  22. Generating a globally unique identifier in Java
  23. Is there a way to redirect to another Action class without using on struts.xml
  24. How can I pause/sleep/wait in a java swing app?
  25. How to convert a csv file to parquet
  26. Java error – bad source file: file does not contain class x . Please remove or make sure it appears
  27. Java: using endpoint to publish webservice to tomcat server
  28. build-impl.xml:1031: The module has not been deployed
  29. Java generic type
  30. Why Java does not allow overriding equals(Object) in an Enum?

Leave a Comment