Is there a way to implement methods like __len__ or __eq__ as classmethods?

by

What you’re looking for is called a “metaclass”… just like a is an instance of class A, A is an instance of class as well, referred to as a metaclass. By default, Python classes are instances of the type class (the only exception is under Python 2, which has some legacy “old style” classes, which are those which don’t inherit from object). You can check this by doing type(A)… it should return type itself (yes, that object has been overloaded a little bit).

Metaclasses are powerful and brain-twisting enough to deserve more than the quick explanation I was about to write… a good starting point would be this stackoverflow question: What is a Metaclass.

For your particular question, for Python 3, the following creates a metaclass which aliases len(A) to invoke a class method on A:

class LengthMetaclass(type):

    def __len__(self):
        return self.clslength()

class A(object, metaclass=LengthMetaclass):

    @classmethod
    def clslength(cls):
        return 7

print(len(A))

(Note: Example above is for Python 3. The syntax is slightly different for Python 2: you would use class A(object):\n __metaclass__=LengthMetaclass instead of passing it as a parameter.)

The reason LengthMetaclass.__len__ doesn’t affect instances of A is that attribute resolution in Python first checks the instance dict, then walks the class hierarchy [A, object], but it never consults the metaclasses. Whereas accessing A.__len__ first consults the instance A, then walks it’s class hierarchy, which consists of [LengthMetaclass, type].

More Related Contents:

  1. I want to know why "Word('zhiying') == Word('navaln')" is true?
  2. How to avoid having class data shared among instances?
  3. What is the difference between old style and new style classes in Python?
  4. Why is the id of a Python class not unique when called quickly?
  5. How to create a custom string representation for a class object?
  6. How do I use method overloading in Python?
  7. What is the difference between class and instance variables?
  8. python class instance variables and class variables
  9. List attributes of an object [duplicate]
  10. How to return a value from __init__ in Python?
  11. How to create a read-only class property in Python? [duplicate]
  12. Attaching a decorator to all functions within a class
  13. Defining “boolness” of a class in python
  14. How do I access Class member variables in Python?
  15. Monkey patching a class in another module in Python
  16. class variables is shared across all instances in python? [duplicate]
  17. AttributeError: ‘datetime’ module has no attribute ‘strptime’
  18. How do you create an incremental ID in a Python Class
  19. assigning class variable as default value to class method argument
  20. What are the parentheses for at the end of Python method names? [duplicate]
  21. “__init__” vs “__call__” in python class
  22. Class (Static) variables and methods in Python
  23. Does python `str()` function call `__str__()` function of a class?
  24. Passing variables, creating instances, self, The mechanics and usage of classes: need explanation [closed]
  25. How do you change the value of one attribute by changing the value of another? (dependent attributes)
  26. What’s an example use case for a Python classmethod?
  27. Python using methods from other classes
  28. Are functions objects in Python?
  29. Provide __classcell__ example for Python 3.6 metaclass
  30. Type Hinting for objects of type that’s being defined [duplicate]

Leave a Comment