Java protected fields vs public getters

by

If there’s going to be a public getter anyway, why would you want to expose the field itself more widely than absolutely necessary? That means it’s immediately writable by subclasses (unless it’s final to start with).

Personally I like all my fields to be private: it provides a cleaner separation between API and implementation. I regard the relationship between a superclass and a subclass as similar to that of a caller and callee – changes to the underlying implementation shouldn’t break subclasses any more than they should break callers. The name of a field is an implementation detail which shouldn’t impact other classes.

Admittedly my view is occasionally seen as somewhat extreme…

More Related Contents:

  1. how to execute same piece of code for both if and else
  2. Implementing back/forward buttons in Swing
  3. No compiler is provided in this environment. Perhaps you are running on a JRE rather than a JDK?
  4. Running junit tests in parallel in a Maven build?
  5. What is “String args[]”? parameter in main method Java
  6. Sockets: Discover port availability using Java
  7. Android FTP Library [closed]
  8. proper hibernate annotation for byte[]
  9. How to deserialise a subclass in Firebase using getValue(Subclass.class)
  10. “Uncompilable source code” RuntimeException in netbeans
  11. How can I enumerate all classes in a package and add them to a List?
  12. Java Executors: how can I set task priority?
  13. How can you get an Android user’s email address?
  14. JFrame.dispose() vs System.exit()
  15. @PreUpdate and @Prepersist in hibernate/JPA (using session)
  16. Convert between LocalDate and sql.Date [duplicate]
  17. Favor composition over inheritance [duplicate]
  18. How does `this` reference to an outer class escape through publishing inner class instance?
  19. Hibernate/JPA DB Schema Generation Best Practices
  20. How to do an HTTPS POST from Android?
  21. Does close ever throw an IOException?
  22. JApplet creates a ball that bounces and gets progressively less high in Java
  23. keylistener not working after clicking button
  24. How can I reliably simulate touch events on Android without root (like Automate and Tasker)?
  25. Cleanup after all junit tests
  26. Difference between pure and impure function?
  27. How do you enforce foreign key constraints in SQLite through Java?
  28. Java Primitive Types: int vs. Integer
  29. Different design for landscape and portrait orientation android
  30. Maven- No plugin found for prefix ‘spring-boot’ in the current project and in the plugin groups

Leave a Comment