JavaScript function binding (this keyword) is lost after assignment

by

john.greet("Mark") actually calls a function. When you do var fx = john.greet;, you’re getting a reference to the function. So when you call it, this is not bound to john. What you’re actually doing is window.fx("Mark") and so this is the window object. You were on the right track when you said that it was in the global context. In this particular instance, the global object is window, and so fx is actually window.fx.

When you have a function reference you should use call or apply if you want to set the value of this. Try doing this:

fx.call(john, "Mark");

The first argument in call or apply is the value used for this in the context of the function call.

EDIT

Some people mentioned that the real issue here might be confusion surrounding an object literal vs. an instance of an object. You’re creating an object literal which also behaves kind of like a singleton. You cannot create a new instance of that object. In this case john is a reference to that object literal. In that context, this in the function greet refers to the object literal itself. Hence when you call john.greet("Mark"), this is bound to john.

When you grab a reference to john.greet just by itself and assigning it to a global variable, you’re essentially doing this:

var fx = function(person) {
   alert("Hi " + person + ", my name is " + this.name);
}

In this scenario, this is window, because fx is basically window.fx (since the global object here is window. Assuming this code was wrapped inside another function, then the global object would refer to that function.

If you want to create multiple instances of an object, you can do something like this:

var Person = function(name) {
    var self = this; //maintains a reference to the instance

    this.name = name;
    this.greet = function(name) {
        alert("Hi " + name + ", my name is " + self.name);
    }
}

var john = new Person("John");
john.greet("Mark"); // alerts "Hi Mark, my name is John"

var fx = john.greet;
fx("Mark"); // also alerts "Hi Mark, my name is John"

Here, the self variable (which is local to the function) maintains a reference to the actual instance because you’re binding it to this when you create the object.

There are many best practices associated with OOP in Javascript. You can Google and find out (there are many links). I recommend reading stuff from Douglas Crockford especially.

More Related Contents:

  1. How do I add a delay in a JavaScript loop?
  2. FATAL ERROR: Ineffective mark-compacts near heap limit Allocation failed – JavaScript heap out of memory in Ionic 3
  3. How to make cross domain request [duplicate]
  4. When serving JavaScript files, is it better to use the application/javascript or application/x-javascript
  5. How to set locale in DatePipe in Angular 2?
  6. JavaScript – why Array.prototype.fill actually fills a “pointer” of object when filling anything like ‘new Object()’
  7. this.setState isn’t merging states as I would expect
  8. In javascript how can I dynamically get a nested property of an object
  9. Why are objects’ values captured inside function calls?
  10. Why is the variable holding the input value always logged as empty?
  11. How to ONLY trigger parent click event when a child is clicked
  12. Doing links like Twitter, Hash-Bang #! URL’s [duplicate]
  13. gapless looping audio html5
  14. Find out if someone has a role
  15. Resize a Base-64 image in JavaScript without using canvas
  16. How do I count a JavaScript object’s attributes? [duplicate]
  17. Best way to alphanumeric check in JavaScript
  18. What is the difference between `firstChild` and `firstElementChild`?
  19. How to extract extension from filename string in Javascript? [duplicate]
  20. ng-repeat with ng-transclude inside a directive
  21. How to get difference between 2 Dates in Years, Months and days using moment.js
  22. How to resolve the Syntax error : await is only valid in async function?
  23. How do I export multiple html tables to excel?
  24. querySelectorAll.style does not work
  25. How to generate unique ID with node.js
  26. knockout.js using $index with if binding
  27. Trying to use React.DOM to set body styles
  28. How to have nested loops with map in JSX?
  29. Error when requiring discordjs: “cannot find module ‘node:events'” [duplicate]
  30. Ruby on Rails – Send JavaScript variable from controller to external Javascript asset file

Leave a Comment