No it is not possible. It is the same as:
exampleObject.key1 = something;
exampleObject.key1 = something else; // over writes the old value
I think the best thing here would be to use an array:
var obj = {
key1: []
};
obj.key1.push("something"); // useing the key directly
obj['key1'].push("something else"); // using the key reference
console.log(obj);
// ======= OR ===========
var objArr = [];
objArr.push({
key1: 'something'
});
objArr.push({
key1: 'something else'
});
console.log(objArr);