Overload resolution issue for generic method with constraints

by

Does compiler take into account type parameter constraints at all, when resolving overloads?

No, because generic constraints are not part of the function signature. You can verify this by adding a Bar overload that is identical except for the generic constraints:

interface IBar { }

static void Bar<T>(IEnumerable<T> value)
    where T : IFoo
{
}

static void Bar<T>(T source)
    where T : IBar
{
    // fails to compile : Type ____ already defines a member called 'Bar' with the same parameter types
}

The reason your code doesn’t compile is because the compiler chooses the “best” match based on the method signature, then tries to apply the generic constraints.

One possible reason why it doesn’t is because this call would be ambiguous:

{suppose List<T> had an Add<T>(IEnumerable<T> source) method}

List<object> junk = new List<object>();
junk.Add(1);   // OK
junk.Add("xyzzy") // OK
junk.Add(new [] {1, 2, 3, 4});  //ambiguous - do you intend to add the _array_ or the _contents_ of the array?

The obvious fix is to use a different name for the Bar method that takes a collection (as is done in the BCL with Add and AddRange.

More Related Contents:

  1. How to capture value OOPS & Generic [closed]
  2. Nullable type as a generic parameter possible?
  3. Generic constraint to match numeric types [duplicate]
  4. Null or default comparison of generic argument in C#
  5. Combination of List
  6. c# covariant return types utilizing generics
  7. Passing a single item as IEnumerable
  8. Static Generic Class as Dictionary
  9. Converting a generic list to a CSV string
  10. Get a generic method without using GetMethods
  11. Anonymous Types – Are there any distingushing characteristics?
  12. C# Get Generic Type Name
  13. T must be contravariantly valid
  14. Can I Create a Dictionary of Generic Types?
  15. How to Pass Parameters to Activator.CreateInstance()
  16. C#: System.Object vs Generics
  17. Why does a generic type constraint result in a no implicit reference conversion error?
  18. Understanding C# generics much better
  19. How can I get the correct text definition of a generic type using reflection?
  20. What’s Wrong with an ArrayList?
  21. Implementing arithmetic in generics?
  22. Filtering out values from a C# Generic Dictionary
  23. Casting array to IEnumerable
  24. How do generics get compiled by the JIT compiler?
  25. How to convert c# generic list to json using json.net?
  26. Build c# Generic Type definition at runtime
  27. Hashtable to Dictionary syncroot .
  28. Generic list of generic objects
  29. Initializing a Generic variable from a C# Type Variable
  30. Generic Web Api controller to support any model

Leave a Comment