Python sum, why not strings? [closed]

by

Python tries to discourage you from “summing” strings. You’re supposed to join them:

"".join(list_of_strings)

It’s a lot faster, and uses much less memory.

A quick benchmark:

$ python -m timeit -s 'import operator; strings = ["a"]*10000' 'r = reduce(operator.add, strings)'
100 loops, best of 3: 8.46 msec per loop
$ python -m timeit -s 'import operator; strings = ["a"]*10000' 'r = "".join(strings)'
1000 loops, best of 3: 296 usec per loop

Edit (to answer OP’s edit): As to why strings were apparently “singled out”, I believe it’s simply a matter of optimizing for a common case, as well as of enforcing best practice: you can join strings much faster with ”.join, so explicitly forbidding strings on sum will point this out to newbies.

BTW, this restriction has been in place “forever”, i.e., since the sum was added as a built-in function (rev. 32347)

More Related Contents:

  1. Python: Can a subclass of float take extra arguments in its constructor?
  2. How to determine a Python variable’s type?
  3. Change column type in pandas
  4. How to check if string input is a number?
  5. Sum a list of numbers in Python
  6. Strings in a DataFrame, but dtype is object
  7. How is the ‘is’ keyword implemented in Python?
  8. Store different datatypes in one NumPy array?
  9. List vs tuple, when to use each? [duplicate]
  10. How to sum dict elements
  11. Fastest way to convert a dict’s keys & values from `unicode` to `str`?
  12. Add SUM of values of two LISTS into new LIST
  13. What is the most pythonic way to check if an object is a number?
  14. Complex numbers in python
  15. How to check if an object is a list or tuple (but not string)?
  16. Exponentials in python: x**y vs math.pow(x, y)
  17. Correct way to detect sequence parameter?
  18. How can I check if my python object is a number? [duplicate]
  19. Override the {…} notation so i get an OrderedDict() instead of a dict()?
  20. What is dtype(‘O’), in pandas?
  21. Generate all possible lists of length N that sum to S in Python
  22. Sum function prob TypeError: unsupported operand type(s) for +: ‘int’ and ‘str’
  23. Get total of Pandas column
  24. How do you set a conditional in python based on datatypes?
  25. Possible to enforce type hints?
  26. Do union types actually exist in python?
  27. Python Numpy Data Types Performance
  28. What’s the best way to sum all values in a Pandas dataframe? [duplicate]
  29. Can i set float128 as the standard float-array in numpy
  30. how to count the total number of lines in a text file using python

Leave a Comment