Scala String vs java.lang.String – type inference

by

This is a very good question! First, let me assure you that you can safely specify the return type.

Now, let’s look into it… yes, when left to inference, Scala infers java.lang.String, instead of just String. So, if you look up “String” in the ScalaDoc, you won’t find anything, which seems to indicate it is not a Scala class either. Well, it has to come from someplace, though.

Let’s consider what Scala imports by default. You can find it by yourself on the REPL:

scala> :imports
 1) import java.lang._             (155 types, 160 terms)
 2) import scala._                 (801 types, 809 terms)
 3) import scala.Predef._          (16 types, 167 terms, 96 are implicit)

The first two are packages — and, indeed, String can be found on java.lang! Is that it, then? Let’s check by instantiating something else from that package:

scala> val s: StringBuffer = new StringBuffer
s: java.lang.StringBuffer =

scala> val s: String = new String
s: String = ""

So, that doesn’t seem to be it. Now, it can’t be inside the scala package, or it would have been found when looking up on the ScalaDoc. So let’s look inside scala.Predef, and there it is!

type String = String

That means String is an alias for java.lang.String (which was imported previously). That looks like a cyclic reference though, but if you check the source, you’ll see it is defined with the full path:

type String        = java.lang.String

Next, you might want to ask why? Well, I don’t have any idea, but I suspect it is to make such an important class a little less dependent on the JVM.

More Related Contents:

  1. Difference between text and varchar (character varying)
  2. scala string.split does not work
  3. Better String formatting in Scala
  4. Efficiently repeat a character/string n times in Scala
  5. How to split a string by a string in Scala
  6. Multiple parameter closure argument type not inferred
  7. What is the difference between String and string in C#?
  8. What is the difference between String and string in C#?
  9. Parse usable Street Address, City, State, Zip from a string [closed]
  10. “The argument type ‘String?’ can’t be assigned to the parameter type ‘String'” when using stdin.readLineSync()
  11. Format a Go string without printing?
  12. C++/CLI Converting from System::String^ to std::string
  13. In Bash, how can I check if a string begins with some value?
  14. Using on a List doesn’t update model values
  15. Making a string concatenation operator in R
  16. What are type lambdas in Scala and what are their benefits?
  17. Replacing some characters in a string with another character
  18. Bash: Split string into character array
  19. Reading a file line by line in Go
  20. Replacing characters in Ant property
  21. How do I convert a Vec to Vec?
  22. How do I concatenate strings in Swift?
  23. How to infer the type of an expression manually
  24. What is the difference between a “line feed” and a “carriage return”?
  25. Is there an owned version of String::chars?
  26. How to split a string in Haskell?
  27. Repeat and concatenate a string N times
  28. Is there “\n” equivalent in VBscript?
  29. Missing parameter type error by calling toSet?
  30. scala f-bounded types explanation

Leave a Comment