Shell redirection i/o order

by

The Bash manual has a clear example (similar to yours) to show that the order matters and also explains the difference. Here’s the relevant part excerpted (emphasis mine):

Note that the order of redirections is significant. For example, the
command

ls > dirlist 2>&1

directs both standard output (file descriptor 1) and standard error
(file descriptor 2) to the file dirlist, while the command

ls 2>&1 > dirlist

directs only the standard output to file dirlist, because the standard
error was made a copy of the standard output before the standard
output was redirected to dirlist.

This post explains it from the POSIX viewpoint.

Confusions happen due to a key difference. > redirects not by making left operand (stderr) point to right operand (stdout) but by making a copy of the right operand and assigning it to the left. Conceptually, assignment by copy and not by reference.

So reading from left-to-right which is how this is interpreted by Bash: ls > dirlist 2>&1 means redirect stdout to the file dirlist, followed by redirection of stderr to whatever stdout is currently (which is already the file dirlist). However, ls 2>&1 > dirlist would redirect stderr to whatever stdout is currently (which is the screen/terminal) and then redirect stdout to dirlist.

More Related Contents:

  1. Redirect stderr and stdout in Bash [duplicate]
  2. How to redirect and append both standard output and standard error to a file with Bash
  3. How to redirect both stdout and stderr to a file [duplicate]
  4. How can I pipe stderr, and not stdout?
  5. How to store standard error in a variable
  6. Capture stdout and stderr into different variables
  7. Bash script – store stderr in a variable [duplicate]
  8. Piping both stdout and stderr in bash?
  9. Capture both stdout and stderr in Bash [duplicate]
  10. How to pipe stdout while keeping it on screen ? (and not to a output file)
  11. How do file descriptors work?
  12. pipe stdout and stderr to two different processes in shell script?
  13. what exactly env command do? [duplicate]
  14. What is the purpose of the : (colon) GNU Bash builtin?
  15. How do I check if a directory exists in a Bash shell script?
  16. Checking from shell script if a directory contains files
  17. Count occurrences of a char in a string using Bash
  18. How to redirect output of an entire shell script within the script itself?
  19. Should aliases go in .bashrc or .bash_profile? [duplicate]
  20. How to read user input into a variable in Bash?
  21. What is the difference between ${var}, “$var”, and “${var}” in the Bash shell?
  22. What is the exact meaning of IFS=$’\n’?
  23. source command not found in sh shell
  24. How to check if a file contains a specific string using Bash
  25. How to check if running in Cygwin, Mac or Linux?
  26. How to split a file into equal parts, without breaking individual lines? [duplicate]
  27. Why does “local” discard the return code of a command?
  28. What does “<
  29. Assign a makefile variable value to a bash command result?
  30. Comparing PHP version numbers using Bash?

Leave a Comment