stdcall and cdecl

by

Raymond Chen gives a nice overview of what __stdcall and __cdecl does.

(1) The caller “knows” to clean up the stack after calling a function because the compiler knows the calling convention of that function and generates the necessary code.

void __stdcall StdcallFunc() {}

void __cdecl CdeclFunc()
{
    // The compiler knows that StdcallFunc() uses the __stdcall
    // convention at this point, so it generates the proper binary
    // for stack cleanup.
    StdcallFunc();
}

It is possible to mismatch the calling convention, like this:

LRESULT MyWndProc(HWND hwnd, UINT msg,
    WPARAM wParam, LPARAM lParam);
// ...
// Compiler usually complains but there's this cast here...
windowClass.lpfnWndProc = reinterpret_cast<WNDPROC>(&MyWndProc);

So many code samples get this wrong it’s not even funny. It’s supposed to be like this:

// CALLBACK is #define'd as __stdcall
LRESULT CALLBACK MyWndProc(HWND hwnd, UINT msg
    WPARAM wParam, LPARAM lParam);
// ...
windowClass.lpfnWndProc = &MyWndProc;

However, assuming the programmer doesn’t ignore compiler errors, the compiler will generate the code needed to clean up the stack properly since it’ll know the calling conventions of the functions involved.

(2) Both ways should work. In fact, this happens quite frequently at least in code that interacts with the Windows API, because __cdecl is the default for C and C++ programs according to the Visual C++ compiler and the WinAPI functions use the __stdcall convention.

(3) There should be no real performance difference between the two.

More Related Contents:

  1. Why are Cdecl calls often mismatched in the “standard” P/Invoke Convention?
  2. Pointers with c++ [duplicate]
  3. No member named ” in ”. Why did it happen and how do I fix it?
  4. How do I print the content of a file?
  5. My attempt at value initialization is interpreted as a function declaration, and why doesn’t A a(()); solve it?
  6. to_string is not a member of std, says g++ (mingw)
  7. Accessing class members on a NULL pointer
  8. Are “anonymous structs” standard? And, really, what *are* they?
  9. Initializing a two dimensional std::vector
  10. C++ cout hex values?
  11. How to create minidump for my process when it crashes?
  12. Calling python from a c++ program for distribution
  13. Discards qualifiers error
  14. Why does -INT_MIN = INT_MIN in a signed, two’s complement representation?
  15. Function declaration inside or outside the class
  16. Detailed guide on using gcov with CMake/CDash?
  17. Skipping Incompatible Libraries at compile
  18. std::put_time implementation status in GCC?
  19. Reverse map lookup
  20. Using the less than comparison operator for strings
  21. Where can I learn more about C++0x? [closed]
  22. What’s the difference between the WIN32 and _WIN32 defines in C++
  23. scanf on an istream object
  24. Somehow register my classes in a list
  25. Printing all environment variables in C / C++
  26. Should I use virtual, override, or both keywords?
  27. Building Qt5 with Visual Studio 2012 / Visual Studio 2013, and integrating with the IDE
  28. Creating N nested for-loops
  29. Set local environment variables in C++
  30. Why is pow(int, int) so slow?

Leave a Comment