Using explicitly numbered repetition instead of question mark, star and plus

by

To my knowledge they are identical. I think there maybe a few engines out there that don’t support the numbered syntax but I’m not sure which. I vaguely recall a question on SO a few days ago where explicit notation wouldn’t work in Notepad++.

The only time I would use explicitly numbered repetition is when the repetition is greater than 1:

  • Exactly two: {2}
  • Two or more: {2,}
  • Two to four: {2,4}

I tend to prefer these especially when the repeated pattern is more than a few characters. If you have to match 3 numbers, some people like to write: \d\d\d but I would rather write \d{3} since it emphasizes the number of repetitions involved. Furthermore, down the road if that number ever needs to change, I only need to change {3} to {n} and not re-parse the regex in my head or worry about messing it up; it requires less mental effort.

If that criteria isn’t met, I prefer the shorthand. Using the “explicit” notation quickly clutters up the pattern and makes it hard to read. I’ve worked on a project where some developers didn’t know regex too well (it’s not exactly everyone’s favorite topic) and I saw a lot of {1} and {0,1} occurrences. A few people would ask me to code review their pattern and that’s when I would suggest changing those occurrences to shorthand notation and save space and, IMO, improve readability.

More Related Contents:

  1. RegEx for Multi-Words Without Numbers and Any Special Characters
  2. What is this pattern “\\s*\\^++\\s*” used for? [duplicate]
  3. Regular expression to match balanced parentheses
  4. How do I deal with special characters like \^$.?*|+()[{ in my regex?
  5. How do (*SKIP) or (*F) work on regex?
  6. How can test I regular expressions using multiple RE engines? [closed]
  7. Regular expression for first and last name
  8. The recognizing power of “modern” regexes
  9. What is “The Best” U.S. Currency RegEx?
  10. Regular expression for exact match of a string
  11. Regular expression for matching latitude/longitude coordinates?
  12. How can I “inverse match” with regex?
  13. regular expression for Indian mobile numbers
  14. Delete all content but keeping matched
  15. Removing empty lines in Notepad++
  16. regex for zip-code
  17. Bash, grep between two lines with specified string
  18. Regex to match 2 digits, optional decimal, two digits
  19. Extracting top-level and second-level domain from a URL using regex
  20. Match Question Mark in mod_rewrite rule regex
  21. HTML5 input pattern search for quote
  22. When should I not use regular expressions?
  23. Replace a word with multiple lines using sed?
  24. Regular Expression Vs. String Parsing
  25. .htaccess RewriteRule to path without changing URL
  26. Can extended regex implementations parse HTML?
  27. How to get Vim to highlight non-ascii characters?
  28. Regexp for subdomain
  29. Bash – Regex for HTML contents
  30. Extracting text after last period in string [duplicate]

Leave a Comment