Using intptr_t instead of void*?

by

Is it a good idea to use intptr_t as a general-purpose storage (to hold pointers and integer values) instead of void*?

No.

intptr_t is not guaranteed to exist. First, as you note, it was introduced in C99. Second, implementations are not required to have an integer type big enough to hold converted pointer values without loss of information.

Converting an int to intptr_t and back is unlikely to lose information but there’s no actual guarantee that intptr_t is wider than int.

If you want to store pointer values, store them in pointer objects. That’s what pointer objects are for.

Any pointer to an object or incomplete type can be converted to void* and back again without loss of information. There is no such guarantee for pointers to functions — but any pointer-to-function type can be converted to any other pointer-to-function-type and back without loss of information. (I’m referring to the C standard; I think POSIX provides some additional guarantees.)

If you want to store either an integer or a pointer value in the same object, the first thing you should do is re-think your design. If you’ve already done so, and concluded that you really do want to do this, consider using a union (and keeping careful track of what kind of value you’ve stored most recently).

There are APIs that use a void* argument to allow arbitrary data to be passed; see, for example, the POSIX pthread_create() function. This can be abused by casting an integer value to void* but it’s safer to pass the address of an integer object.

More Related Contents:

  1. C isn’t that hard: void ( *( *f[] ) () ) ()
  2. Casting void pointers
  3. Pointers program
  4. Are there differences between pointers to object stored on stack and heap? [closed]
  5. With arrays, why is it the case that a[5] == 5[a]?
  6. What is the difference between char * const and const char *?
  7. In C, are arrays pointers or used as pointers?
  8. Are all data pointers the same size in one platform for all data types? [duplicate]
  9. Why can’t I convert ‘char**’ to a ‘const char* const*’ in C?
  10. size_t vs. uintptr_t
  11. C function pointer casting to void pointer
  12. Difference between char *str=”STRING” and char str[] = “STRING”?
  13. How to increment a pointer address and pointer’s value?
  14. How to printf a memory address in C
  15. What is the difference between far pointers and near pointers?
  16. Why can I change a local const variable through pointer casts but not a global one in C?
  17. Pointer Arithmetic: ++*ptr or *ptr++?
  18. Range of values in C Int and Long 32 – 64 bits
  19. Is the compiler allowed to recycle freed pointer variables?
  20. Returning Arrays/Pointers from a function
  21. why is array name a pointer to the first element of the array?
  22. C – Accessing data AFTER memory has been free()ed?
  23. allocate matrix in C
  24. Passing two-dimensional array via pointer
  25. Getting the size of a malloc only with the returned pointer
  26. Mis-aligned pointers on x86
  27. How to find the size of an array (from a pointer pointing to the first element array)?
  28. Can I treat a struct like an array?
  29. In C, is it good form to use typedef for a pointer?
  30. What is the function of an asterisk before a function name?

Leave a Comment