What requirement was the tuple designed to solve?

by

When writing programs it is extremely common to want to logically group together a set of values which do not have sufficient commonality to justify making a class.

Many programming languages allow you to logically group together a set of otherwise unrelated values without creating a type in only one way:

void M(int foo, string bar, double blah)

Logically this is exactly the same as a method M that takes one argument which is a 3-tuple of int, string, double. But I hope you would not actually make:

class MArguments
{
   public int Foo { get; private set; } 
   ... etc

unless MArguments had some other meaning in the business logic.

The concept of “group together a bunch of otherwise unrelated data in some structure that is more lightweight than a class” is useful in many, many places, not just for formal parameter lists of methods. It’s useful when a method has two things to return, or when you want to key a dictionary off of two data rather than one, and so on.

Languages like F# which support tuple types natively provide a great deal of flexibility to their users; they are an extremely useful set of data types. The BCL team decided to work with the F# team to standardize on one tuple type for the framework so that every language could benefit from them.

However, there is at this point no language support for tuples in C#. Tuples are just another data type like any other framework class; there’s nothing special about them. We are considering adding better support for tuples in hypothetical future versions of C#. If anyone has any thoughts on what sort of features involving tuples you’d like to see, I’d be happy to pass them along to the design team. Realistic scenarios are more convincing than theoretical musings.

More Related Contents:

  1. Combine elements of a list [closed]
  2. C# using Tuple with Sum [closed]
  3. What’s the difference between System.ValueTuple and System.Tuple?
  4. Tuples( or arrays ) as Dictionary keys in C#
  5. Better naming in Tuple classes than “Item1”, “Item2”
  6. How to easily initialize a list of Tuples?
  7. Equivalent of Tuple (.NET 4) for .NET Framework 3.5
  8. Will a future version of .NET support tuples in C#?
  9. Why I could not serialize a tuple in C#? [duplicate]
  10. Using a C# 7 tuple in an ASP.NET Core Web API Controller
  11. Is Using .NET 4.0 Tuples in my C# Code a Poor Design Decision?
  12. Get all pairs in a list using LINQ
  13. Enumerable and Enumerator [closed]
  14. Understanding garbage collection in .NET
  15. Reading Xml with XmlReader in C#
  16. How to ignore the certificate check when ssl
  17. Using JsonConvert.DeserializeObject to deserialize Json to a C# POCO class
  18. How to read and modify NTFS Alternate Data Streams using .NET [closed]
  19. Interface defining a constructor signature?
  20. Capture a keyboard keypress in the background
  21. WinForm UI Validation
  22. Compare two Lists for differences
  23. c# – Volatile keyword usage vs lock
  24. difference between IComparable and IComparer [duplicate]
  25. Update app.config system.net setting at runtime
  26. Remove columns from DataTable in C#
  27. Index was out of range. Must be non-negative and less than the size of the collection parameter name:index
  28. How to read last “n” lines of log file [duplicate]
  29. When Should I Use Response.Redirect(url, true)?
  30. How to use credentials in HttpClient in c#?

Leave a Comment