What should Timertask.scheduleAtFixedRate do if the clock changes?

by

Looking at the source of Timer for Java 1.7, it appears that is uses System.currentTimeMillis() to determine the next execution of a task.

However, looking at the source of ScheduledThreadPoolExecutor, it uses System.nanoTime().

Which means you won’t see that behaviour if you use one in place of a Timer. To create one, use, for instance, Executors.newScheduledThreadPool().

Why you wouldn’t see this behaviour is because of what the doc for System.nanoTime() says:

This method can only be used to measure elapsed time and is not related to any other notion of system or wall-clock time. The value returned represents nanoseconds since some fixed but arbitrary origin time [emphasis mine].

As to whether this is a bug in Timer, maybe…

Note that unlike a ScheduledExecutorService, a Timer supports absolute time, and maybe this explains its use of System.currentTimeMillis(); also, Timer has been there since Java 1.3 while System.nanoTime() only appears in 1.5.

But a consequence of using System.currentTimeMillis() is that Timer is sensitive to the system date/time… And that is not documented in the javadoc.

More Related Contents:

  1. How to run certain task every day at a particular time using ScheduledExecutorService?
  2. How do I calculate the elapsed time of an event in Java? [duplicate]
  3. TimerTask vs Thread.sleep vs Handler postDelayed – most accurate to call function every N milliseconds?
  4. How to convert a string to alphabets and add [closed]
  5. Attempt to invoke virtual method ‘android.view.Window$Callback android.view.Window.getCallback()’ on a null object reference
  6. How to add a JAR in NetBeans
  7. How can I save the state of my program and then load it?
  8. How do I convert a Java 8 IntStream to a List?
  9. Lambda Expression and generic defined only in method
  10. What is simplest way to read a file into String? [duplicate]
  11. Use of class definitions inside a method in Java
  12. Parse Web Site HTML with JAVA [duplicate]
  13. Split 1GB Xml file using Java
  14. How to find what SSL/TLS version is used in Java
  15. Stack with find-min/find-max more efficient than O(n)?
  16. JSoup character encoding issue
  17. Could not serialize object cause of HibernateProxy
  18. How to use 3rd party library in Java9 module?
  19. Differences between Runtime/Checked/Unchecked/Error/Exception
  20. Jackson databind enum case insensitive
  21. How is Java’s ThreadLocal implemented under the hood?
  22. Restart the service even if app is force-stopped and Keep running service in background even after closing the app How?
  23. Saving a Java 2d graphics image as .png file
  24. How do I delete files programmatically on Android?
  25. Why Java does not see that Integers are equal?
  26. Change remote repository credentials (authentication) on Intellij IDEA 14
  27. How do I create an int array with randomly shuffled numbers in a given range [duplicate]
  28. Java double comparison epsilon
  29. What are the pitfalls of a Java noob? [closed]
  30. Strange text wrapping with styled text in JTextPane with Java 7

Leave a Comment