What’s the better (cleaner) way to ignore output in PowerShell? [closed]

by

I just did some tests of the four options that I know about.

Measure-Command {$(1..1000) | Out-Null}

TotalMilliseconds : 76.211

Measure-Command {[Void]$(1..1000)}

TotalMilliseconds : 0.217

Measure-Command {$(1..1000) > $null}

TotalMilliseconds : 0.2478

Measure-Command {$null = $(1..1000)}

TotalMilliseconds : 0.2122

## Control, times vary from 0.21 to 0.24
Measure-Command {$(1..1000)}

TotalMilliseconds : 0.2141

So I would suggest that you use anything but Out-Null due to overhead. The next important thing, to me, would be readability. I kind of like redirecting to $null and setting equal to $null myself. I use to prefer casting to [Void], but that may not be as understandable when glancing at code or for new users.

I guess I slightly prefer redirecting output to $null.

Do-Something > $null

Edit

After stej’s comment again, I decided to do some more tests with pipelines to better isolate the overhead of trashing the output.

Here are some tests with a simple 1000 object pipeline.

## Control Pipeline
Measure-Command {$(1..1000) | ?{$_ -is [int]}}

TotalMilliseconds : 119.3823

## Out-Null
Measure-Command {$(1..1000) | ?{$_ -is [int]} | Out-Null}

TotalMilliseconds : 190.2193

## Redirect to $null
Measure-Command {$(1..1000) | ?{$_ -is [int]} > $null}

TotalMilliseconds : 119.7923

In this case, Out-Null has about a 60% overhead and > $null has about a 0.3% overhead.

Addendum 2017-10-16: I originally overlooked another option with Out-Null, the use of the -inputObject parameter. Using this the overhead seems to disappear, however the syntax is different:

Out-Null -inputObject ($(1..1000) | ?{$_ -is [int]})

And now for some tests with a simple 100 object pipeline.

## Control Pipeline
Measure-Command {$(1..100) | ?{$_ -is [int]}}

TotalMilliseconds : 12.3566

## Out-Null
Measure-Command {$(1..100) | ?{$_ -is [int]} | Out-Null}

TotalMilliseconds : 19.7357

## Redirect to $null
Measure-Command {$(1..1000) | ?{$_ -is [int]} > $null}

TotalMilliseconds : 12.8527

Here again Out-Null has about a 60% overhead. While > $null has an overhead of about 4%. The numbers here varied a bit from test to test (I ran each about 5 times and picked the middle ground). But I think it shows a clear reason to not use Out-Null.

More Related Contents:

  1. The ‘
  2. Is there a way to set a variable up to place output to stdout or null?
  3. Why and how are these two $null values different?
  4. UTF-8 output from PowerShell
  5. How do I call the PowerShell CLI robustly, with respect to character encoding, input and output streams, quoting and escaping?
  6. Why is an empty PowerShell pipeline not the same as null?
  7. this code my teacher gave it to us as homework and it does not work with me idk why
  8. How can you use an object’s property in a double-quoted string?
  9. Powershell: passing json string to curl
  10. How can I replace every occurrence of a String in a file with PowerShell?
  11. Function return value in PowerShell
  12. PowerShell’s parsing modes: argument (command) mode vs. expression mode
  13. How do I capture the output into a variable from an external process in PowerShell?
  14. Output (“echo”) a variable to a text file
  15. Powershell equivalent of bash ampersand (&) for forking/running background processes
  16. Parameter interpretation when running jobs
  17. Powershell: Uninstall application by UpgradeCode
  18. How to properly -filter multiple strings in a PowerShell copy script
  19. Methods to hex edit binary files via Powershell
  20. Unable to convert a string to an integer variable from DateTaken attribute on a JPG file
  21. How to Grant permission to user on Certificate private key using powershell?
  22. Using Invoke-Command -ScriptBlock on a function with arguments
  23. Powershell – Reboot and Continue Script
  24. How can I execute an external program with parameters in PowerShell?
  25. Rename file on FTP with PowerShell
  26. Does PowerShell support HashTable Serialization?
  27. Using Powershell environmental variables as strings when outputting files
  28. Create Outlook email draft using PowerShell
  29. Remove last line from file with Powershell
  30. How to return specific data type from PowerShell function i.e. DataTable

Leave a Comment