What’s the correct way to use printf to print a clock_t?

by

There seems to be no perfect way. The root of the problem is that clock_t can be either integer or floating point.

clock_t can be a floating point type

As Bastien Léonard mentions for POSIX (go upvote him), C99 N1256 draft 7.23.1/3 also says that:

[clock_t is] arithmetic types capable of representing times

and 6.2.5/18:

Integer and floating types are collectively called arithmetic types.

and the standard defines arithmetic type as either integers or floating point types.

If you will divide by CLOCKS_PER_SEC, use long double

The return value of clock() is implementation defined, and the only way to get standard meaning out of it is to divide by CLOCKS_PER_SEC to find the number of seconds:

clock_t t0 = clock();
/* Work. */
clock_t t1 = clock();
printf("%Lf", (long double)(t1 - t0));

This is good enough, although not perfect, for the two following reasons:

  • there seems to be no analogue to intmax_t for floating point types: How to get the largest precision floating point data type of implemenation and its printf specifier? So if a larger floating point type comes out tomorrow, it could be used and break your implementation.

  • if clock_t is an integer, the cast to float is well defined to use the nearest float possible. You may lose precision, but it would not matter much compared to the absolute value, and would only happen for huge amounts of time, e.g. long int in x86 is the 80-bit float with 64-bit significant, which is millions of years in seconds.

Go upvote lemonad who said something similar.

If you suppose it is an integer, use %ju and uintmax_t

Although unsigned long long is currently the largest standard integer type possible:

so it is best to typecast to the largest unsigned integer type possible:

#include <stdint.h>

printf("%ju", (uintmax_t)(clock_t)1);

uintmax_t is guaranteed to have the size of the largest possible integer size on the machine.

uintmax_t and its printf specifier %ju were introduced in c99 and gcc for example implements them.

As a bonus, this solves once and for all the question of how to reliably printf integer types (which is unfortunately not the necessarily the case for clock_t).

What could go wrong if it was a double:

  • if too large to fit into the integer, undefined behavior
  • much smaller than 1, will get rounded to 0 and you won’t see anything

Since those consequences are much harsher than the integer to float conversion, using float is likely a better idea.

On glibc 2.21 it is an integer

The manual says that using double is a better idea:

On GNU/Linux and GNU/Hurd systems, clock_t is equivalent to long int and CLOCKS_PER_SEC is an integer value. But in other systems, both clock_t and the macro CLOCKS_PER_SEC can be either integer or floating-point types. Casting CPU time values to double, as in the example above, makes sure that operations such as arithmetic and printing work properly and consistently no matter what the underlying representation is.

In glibc 2.21:

See also

More Related Contents:

  1. Difference between fprintf, printf and sprintf?
  2. What is the correct printf specifier for printing pid_t
  3. how to enter a function to a file in c
  4. Function does not return printf
  5. Please explain the difference in the printfs below
  6. decimal of numbers in c
  7. Why does printf not flush after the call unless a newline is in the format string?
  8. Printing leading 0’s in C
  9. What is the argument for printf that formats a long?
  10. How to printf “unsigned long” in C?
  11. using printf to print out floating values
  12. How to control the number of exponent digits after ‘e’ in C printf %e?
  13. How to use “zd” specifier with `printf()`?
  14. Unsigned values in C
  15. How to combine two 32-bit integers into one 64-bit integer?
  16. Centering strings with printf()
  17. Passing too many arguments to printf
  18. printf with “%d” of numbers starting with 0 (ex “0102”) giving unexpected answer (ex ‘”66″)
  19. What is the conversion specifier for printf that formats a long?
  20. Wrong format specifiers in scanf (or) printf
  21. What primitive data type is time_t? [duplicate]
  22. Does C have a string type? [closed]
  23. why C clock() returns 0
  24. Is it possible to print out only a certain section of a C-string, without making a separate substring?
  25. Printf long long int in C with GCC?
  26. cross-platform printing of 64-bit integers with printf
  27. What precisely does the %g printf specifier mean?
  28. Reading a file character by character in C
  29. Printf without newline in assembly
  30. In C how do I print filename of file that is redirected as input in shell

Leave a Comment