Which is the smarter git protocol, ssh or git(over ssh) or https protocol?

by

Update 2010-2014:

Both ssh and https are equivalent, since Git 1.6.6+ (2010) and the implementation of smart http protocol:

smart http

You now can use ssh or https for read/write access to your repos.
You can also detect if your remote server supports smart http.
Add the right environment variable if you have to use a proxy.

Q3 2015, as Yousha Aleayoub mentions in the comments:

GitHub “Which remote URL should I use?”

The https:// clone URLs are available on all repositories, public and private.
They are smart, so they will provide you with either read-only or read/write access, depending on your permissions to the repository.

The git-http-backend is the:

simple CGI program to serve the contents of a Git repository to Git clients accessing the repository over http:// and https:// protocols.
The program supports clients fetching using both the smart HTTP protocol and the backwards-compatible dumb HTTP protocol, as well as clients pushing using the smart HTTP protocol.

Original answer (July 2010):

From the Pro Git Book:

Probably the most common transport protocol for Git is SSH.
This is because SSH access to servers is already set up in most places — and if it isn’t, it’s easy to do.

SSH is also the only network-based protocol that you can easily read from and write to. The other two network protocols (HTTP and Git) are generally read-only, so even if you have them available for the unwashed masses, you still need SSH for your own write commands.

SSH is also an authenticated network protocol; and because it’s ubiquitous, it’s generally easy to set up and use.

So it is not “smarter” than Git protocol, just a complementary protocol for certain features not addressed by the Git protocol.

The downside of the Git protocol is the lack of authentication. It’s generally undesirable for the Git protocol to be the only access to your project.
Generally, you’ll pair it with SSH access for the few developers who have push (write) access and have everyone else use git:// for read-only access

It also requires firewall access to port 9418, which isn’t a standard port that corporate firewalls always allow. Behind big corporate firewalls, this obscure port is commonly blocked.

(that is why in my shop, I need to use ssh+git and not just git, even for read access: 9418 is blocked…)

More Related Contents:

  1. github: No supported authentication methods available
  2. How to determine the URL that a local Git repository was originally cloned from?
  3. Trying to fix line-endings with git filter-branch, but having no luck
  4. Where do the settings in my Git configuration come from?
  5. How to remove file from Git history?
  6. Git Init in home directory – now unable to commit changes
  7. Does github remember commit IDs?
  8. There is no tracking information for the current branch
  9. How to disable osxkeychain as credential helper in git config?
  10. Msysgit bash is horrendously slow in Windows 7
  11. How can I fetch an unmerged pull request for a branch I don’t own?
  12. Having Trouble Switching Github accounts on terminal
  13. How to compare two different commits on the same branch in github?
  14. How do I avoid the specification of the username and password at every git push?
  15. Repository size limits for GitHub.com
  16. Why Git is not allowing me to commit even after configuration?
  17. Push to GitHub error: Couldn’t find host github.com in the .netrc file; using defaults
  18. How do I add an existing Solution to GitHub from Visual Studio 2013
  19. gitolite push error -> remote: ENV GL_RC not set
  20. Git asks for username every time I push
  21. With GitHub how do I push all branches when adding an existing repo?
  22. Git pushing to remote GitHub repository as wrong user
  23. How to sync with a remote Git repository?
  24. Git push failed, “Non-fast forward updates were rejected”
  25. How to clone git repository from its zip
  26. git push error: src refspec main does not match any on linux
  27. How to install/setup TortoiseGit to work with GitHub
  28. How can I reduce the ever-increasing time to push a subtree?
  29. How to manage multiple ssh keys in the ~/.ssh directory
  30. GitHub Api download zip or tarball link

Leave a Comment