Why C# doesn’t allow inheritance of return type when implementing an Interface

by

UPDATE: This answer was written in 2009. After two decades of people proposing return type covariance for C#, it looks like it will finally be implemented; I am rather surprised. See the bottom of https://devblogs.microsoft.com/dotnet/welcome-to-c-9-0/ for the announcement; I’m sure details will follow.

This feature is called “return type covariance”. C# does not support it for the following reasons:

1) The CLR doesn’t support it. To make it work in C#, we’d have to just spit a whole bunch of little helper methods that do casts on the return type to the right thing. There’s nothing stopping you from doing that yourself.

2) Anders believes that return type covariance is not a good language feature.

3) \We have lots of higher priorities for the language. We have only limited budgets and so we try to only do the best features we can in any given release. Sure, this would be nice, but it’s easy enough to do on your own if you want to. Better that we spend the time adding features that improve the developer experience or add more representational power to the language.

More Related Contents:

  1. How to convert UTF-8 byte[] to string
  2. How to create a simple proxy in C#?
  3. Attempted to read or write protected memory. This is often an indication that other memory is corrupt
  4. Headless browser for C# (.NET)? [closed]
  5. Better way to check if a Path is a File or a Directory?
  6. Check if instance is of a type
  7. Resolve assembly references from another folder
  8. HashSet that preserves ordering
  9. .Net and Bitmap not automatically disposed by GC when there is no memory left
  10. Blocking dialogs in .NET WebBrowser control
  11. ASP.NET MVC – How to show unauthorized error on login page?
  12. Best way to handle Integer overflow in C#?
  13. How can user resize control at runtime in winforms
  14. Is there a tool for finding unreferenced functions (dead, obsolete code) in a C# app? [closed]
  15. Date vs DateTime
  16. MySql Last Insert ID, Connector .net
  17. Timer, event and garbage collection : am I missing something?
  18. Simple animation using C#/Windows Forms
  19. DbContext discard changes without disposing
  20. center MessageBox in parent form [duplicate]
  21. Creating a List of Lists in C#
  22. Ignoring white space for a Regex match
  23. The model item passed into the dictionary is of type ‘mvc.Models.ModelA’ but this dictionary requires a model item of type ‘mvc.Models.ModelB‘
  24. Should thread-safe class have a memory barrier at the end of its constructor?
  25. Does WeakReference make a good cache?
  26. Creating an empty file in C#
  27. What is the use case for the (C# 7.2) “private protected” modifier?
  28. Method Overloading with different return type [duplicate]
  29. Remove top and bottom padding from Text drawn on an Image
  30. Validating user input / Give .NET controls status OK or NOK

Leave a Comment