Why can Java Collections not directly store Primitives types?

by

It was a Java design decision, and one that some consider a mistake. Containers want Objects and primitives don’t derive from Object.

This is one place that .NET designers learned from the JVM and implemented value types and generics such that boxing is eliminated in many cases. In CLR, generic containers can store value types as part of the underlying container structure.

Java opted to add generic support 100% in the compiler without support from the JVM. The JVM being what it is, doesn’t support a “non-object” object. Java generics allow you to pretend there is no wrapper, but you still pay the performance price of boxing. This is IMPORTANT for certain classes of programs.

Boxing is a technical compromise, and I feel it is implementation detail leaking into the language. Autoboxing is nice syntactic sugar, but is still a performance penalty. If anything, I’d like the compiler to warn me when it autoboxes. (For all I know, it may now, I wrote this answer in 2010).

A good explanation on SO about boxing: Why do some languages need Boxing and Unboxing?

And criticism of Java generics: Why do some claim that Java’s implementation of generics is bad?

In Java’s defense, it is easy to look backwards and criticize. The JVM has withstood the test of time, and is a good design in many respects.

More Related Contents:

  1. Most efficient Java primitive collections library [closed]
  2. What is the difference between "collection" ,"Collection" and "Collections"? [duplicate]
  3. Difference between
  4. Properly removing an Integer from a List
  5. Why must local variables, including primitives, always be initialized in Java?
  6. Convert a byte array to integer in Java and vice versa
  7. What is the best way to combine two lists into a map (Java)?
  8. Hibernate Validation of Collections of Primitives
  9. What is the best way get the symmetric difference between two sets in java?
  10. Performance ConcurrentHashmap vs HashMap
  11. What are Reified Generics? How do they solve Type Erasure problems and why can’t they be added without major changes?
  12. What is the difference between an ordered and a sorted collection?
  13. Java – How to create new Entry (key, value)
  14. Why does Collections.sort use Mergesort but Arrays.sort does not?
  15. How to modify a Collection while iterating using for-each loop without ConcurrentModificationException? [duplicate]
  16. Sort a List of objects by multiple fields [duplicate]
  17. Empty an ArrayList or just create a new one and let the old one be garbage collected? [duplicate]
  18. Removing items from a collection in java while iterating over it
  19. what’s a good persistent collections framework for use in java?
  20. Is there a way to get the value of a HashMap randomly in Java?
  21. Difference between a deprecated and a legacy API?
  22. Any implementation of Ordered Set in Java?
  23. JDK9 randomization on immutable sets and maps
  24. In what situations is the CopyOnWriteArrayList suitable? [duplicate]
  25. What Java 8 Stream.collect equivalents are available in the standard Kotlin library?
  26. Create a List of primitive int?
  27. Switch over type in java
  28. How do you know a variable type in java? [duplicate]
  29. How to convert IEEE-11073 16-bit SFLOAT to simple float in Java?
  30. Compare two arrays of primitives in Java?

Leave a Comment