Why can’t two methods be declared with the same signature even though their return types are different? [duplicate]

by

It’s because of type coercion.

Say you have the following functions:

int x(double);
float x(double);

double y = x(1.0);

Now, which of the two prototypes should you call, especially if they do two totally different things?

Basically, a decision was made early on in the language design to only use the function name and arguments to decide which actual function gets called, and we’re stuck with that until a new standard arrives.

Now, you’ve tagged your question C# but I see nothing wrong with designing a language that can do what you suggest. One possibility would be to flag as an error any ambiguous commands like above and force the user to specify which should be called, such as with casting:

int x(double);
float x(double);
double y = (float)(x(1.0));    // overload casting
double y = float:x(1.0);       // or use new syntax (looks nicer, IMNSHO)

This could allow the compiler to choose the right version. This would even work for some issues that other answers have raised. You could turn the ambiguous:

System.out.Println(myClass.MyMethod());

into the specific:

System.out.Println(string:myClass.MyMethod());

This may be possible to get added to C# if it’s not too far into a standards process (and Microsoft will listen) but I don’t think much of your chances getting it added to C or C++ without an awfully large amount of effort. Maybe doing it as an extension to gcc would be easier.

More Related Contents:

  1. Select Tag Helper in ASP.NET Core MVC
  2. List or IList [closed]
  3. Convert integer to binary in C#
  4. Difference between ObservableCollection and BindingList
  5. XML serialization of interface property
  6. Random String Generator Returning Same String [duplicate]
  7. String Concatenation using ‘+’ operator
  8. How to save a List on Settings.Default?
  9. Escape invalid XML characters in C#
  10. .NET Core 2.1 Identity get all users with their associated roles
  11. What is the fastest way to create a checksum for large files in C#
  12. WebAPI StreamContent vs PushStreamContent
  13. Alternate property name while deserializing
  14. Parse and modify a query string in .NET Core
  15. Command dotnet ef not found
  16. Should we always include a default constructor in the class?
  17. WPF Binding – Default value for empty string
  18. Parsing HTML to get content using C#
  19. Decrypt from SHA256
  20. The quest for the Excel custom function tooltip
  21. how to load all assemblies from within your /bin directory
  22. How to define an enum with string value?
  23. Initial capacity of collection types, e.g. Dictionary, List
  24. ‘Date’ is not supported in LINQ to Entities. Only initializers, entity members, and entity navigation properties are supported
  25. What is the difference between Contains and Any in LINQ?
  26. Why events can’t be used in the same way in derived classes as in the base class in C#?
  27. In SpecFlow how can I share data between steps/features?
  28. Is there a way to check to see if another program is running full screen
  29. C# generic methods, type parameters in new() constructor constraint
  30. See if user is part of Active Directory group in C# + Asp.net

Leave a Comment