Why do members of a static class need to be declared as static? Why isn’t it just implicit?

by

I get asked questions like this all the time. Basically the question boils down to “when a fact about a declared member can be deduced by the compiler should the explicit declaration of that fact be (1) required, (2) optional, or (3) forbidden?”

There’s no one easy answer. Each one has to be taken on a case-by-case basis. Putting “static” on a member of a static class is required. Putting “new” on a hiding, non-overriding method of a derived class is optional. Putting “static” on a const is forbidden.

Briefly considering your scenario, it seems bizarre to make it forbidden. You have a whole class full of methods marked “static”. You decide to make the class static and that means you have to remove all the static modifiers? That’s weird.

It seems bizarre to make it optional; suppose you have a static class and two methods, one marked static, one not. Since static is not normally the default, it seems natural to think that there is intended to be a difference between them. Making it optional seems to be potentially confusing.

That leaves making it required, as the least bad of the three options.

See http://blogs.msdn.com/b/ericlippert/archive/2010/06/10/don-t-repeat-yourself-consts-are-already-static.aspx for more thoughts on these sorts of problems.

More Related Contents:

  1. How do I calculate someone’s age based on a DateTime type birthday?
  2. Process.start: how to get the output?
  3. URL Encoding using C#
  4. Using RegEx to balance match parenthesis
  5. Why doesn’t .NET/C# optimize for tail-call recursion?
  6. Cast List to List
  7. how to create an animated gif in .net
  8. Windows Forms Splash Screen – Show a form while loading main form
  9. ASP.NET use SqlConnection connect MySQL
  10. Using Process.Start() to start a process as a different user from within a Windows Service
  11. What is the best practice for “Copy Local” and with project references?
  12. Extending an enum via inheritance
  13. How do I automatically display all properties of a class and their values in a string? [duplicate]
  14. Why \b does not match word using .net regex
  15. Merging two objects in C#
  16. RegEx for an IP Address
  17. Should IDisposable.Dispose() be made safe to call multiple times?
  18. How DataReader works?
  19. Show line number in exception handling
  20. Return to an already open application when a user tries to open a new instance
  21. Illustrating usage of the volatile keyword in C#
  22. smtpclient ” failure sending mail”
  23. How do I prevent print screen
  24. When to use record vs class vs struct
  25. “The operation is not valid for the state of the transaction” error and transaction scope
  26. sizeof() equivalent for reference types?
  27. AES encryption on large files
  28. How to insert a Symbol (Pound, Euro, Copyright) into a Textbox
  29. C# Socket.BeginReceive/EndReceive
  30. Why does StandardOutput.Read() block when StartInfo.RedirectStandardInput is set to true?

Leave a Comment