Why does C# null-conditional operator not work with Unity serializable variables?

by

It does not work in general with anything inheriting from UnityEngine.Object!

It is bypassed due to how they internally implemented the ==/!= method differently. See Custom == operator, should we keep it?

ReSharper explained it pretty well in Possible unintended bypass of lifetime check of underlying Unity engine object

This warning is shown if a type deriving from UnityEngine.Object uses either the null coalescing (??) or null propagation or conditional (?.) operators. These operators do not use the custom equality operators declared on UnityEngine.Object, and so bypass a check to see if the underlying native Unity engine object has been destroyed. An explicit null or boolean comparison, or a call to System.Object.ReferenceEquals() is preferred in order to clarify intent.

UnityEngine.Object is in some occasions not really null but still keeps some meta data. So the underlying object(= System.Object) is not null, UnityEngine.Object‘s overwritten == operator just returns true for == null.

The main reason why therefore things like _tickIcon?.gameObjct throw a NullReferenceException is that the ?. operator only directly works on the underlying object(System.Object) while the UnityEngine.Object works with their custom implementation on a different level.

E.g. after

Destroy(_tickIcon);
_tickIcon.SetActive(false);

you will note that you don’t get a normal NullReferenceException which would be the case if it were actually null but rather get a Unity customs MissingReferenceException telling you a probable reason for why the exception was thrown.

Long story short: As solution UnityEngine.Object has the implicit bool operator

Does the object exist?

The example given there is actually not really true – see above

You should always check the existence of anything derived from UnityEngine.Object like this:

if(_tickIcon)
{
    _tickIcon.SetActive(false);
}

More Related Contents:

  1. Saving/loading data in Unity
  2. Repeated serialization and deserialization creates duplicate items
  3. Detecting Double Clicks not only for the mouse but for every key [closed]
  4. Serialize and Deserialize Json and Json Array in Unity
  5. How do I turn a C# object into a JSON string in .NET?
  6. How to pass data (and references) between scenes in Unity
  7. How can I change property names when serializing with Json.net?
  8. Parsing JSON using Json.net
  9. Unity: Null while making new class instance
  10. How do I get json.net to serialize members of a class deriving from List?
  11. In Unity (C#), why am I getting a NullReferenceException and how do I fix it? [duplicate]
  12. Circular reference detected exception while serializing object to JSON
  13. Can I make XmlSerializer ignore the namespace on deserialization?
  14. Entity framework self referencing loop detected [duplicate]
  15. Deserialize json array stream one item at a time
  16. In Unity, how can I pass values from one script to another?
  17. Is Unityscript/Javascript discontinued?
  18. How to Serialize List?
  19. Deserializing XML File with multiple element attributes – attributes are not deserializing
  20. Unity EventManager with delegate instead of UnityEvent
  21. Why I could not serialize a tuple in C#? [duplicate]
  22. Deserialize Dictionary with enum values in C#
  23. Javascript serialization of DateTime in asp.net is not giving a javascript date object?
  24. Can JavaScriptSerializer exclude properties with null/default values?
  25. Serializing anonymous delegates in C#
  26. Change colors of UI button via script
  27. How do you use XMLSerialize for Enum typed properties in c#?
  28. Deserializing JSON into an object with Json.NET
  29. How to deserialize JSON to objects of the correct type, without having to define the type before hand?
  30. Json.net serialization of custom collection implementing IEnumerable

Leave a Comment