Why does Math.Round(2.5) return 2 instead of 3?

by

Firstly, this wouldn’t be a C# bug anyway – it would be a .NET bug. C# is the language – it doesn’t decide how Math.Round is implemented.

And secondly, no – if you read the docs, you’ll see that the default rounding is “round to even” (banker’s rounding):

Return Value
Type: System.Double
The integer nearest a. If the
fractional component of a is halfway
between two integers, one of which is
even and the other odd, then the even
number is returned. Note that this
method returns a Double instead of an
integral type.

Remarks
The behavior of this method follows IEEE Standard 754,
section 4. This kind of rounding is
sometimes called rounding to nearest,
or banker’s rounding. It minimizes
rounding errors that result from
consistently rounding a midpoint value
in a single direction.

You can specify how Math.Round should round mid-points using an overload which takes a MidpointRounding value. There’s one overload with a MidpointRounding corresponding to each of the overloads which doesn’t have one:

Whether this default was well chosen or not is a different matter. (MidpointRounding was only introduced in .NET 2.0. Before then I’m not sure there was any easy way of implementing the desired behaviour without doing it yourself.) In particular, history has shown that it’s not the expected behaviour – and in most cases that’s a cardinal sin in API design. I can see why Banker’s Rounding is useful… but it’s still a surprise to many.

You may be interested to take a look at the nearest Java equivalent enum (RoundingMode) which offers even more options. (It doesn’t just deal with midpoints.)

More Related Contents:

  1. Why does .NET use banker’s rounding as default?
  2. Why Is ToString() Rounding My Double Value?
  3. WCF – How to Increase Message Size Quota
  4. Can Json.NET serialize / deserialize to / from a stream?
  5. How to troubleshoot a VSTO addin that does not load?
  6. How can I download a file with batch file without using any external tools?
  7. Logging best practices [closed]
  8. Array.Copy vs Buffer.BlockCopy
  9. How do you get a string from a MemoryStream?
  10. Targeting both 32bit and 64bit with Visual Studio in same solution/project
  11. Why don’t structs support inheritance?
  12. How to apply multiple styles in WPF
  13. Linq int to string
  14. What does beforefieldinit flag do?
  15. Are .net finalizers always executed?
  16. Hosting the .NET runtime in a Delphi Program
  17. instance of entity type cannot be tracked because another instance with same key value is tracked [closed]
  18. How to continue field output on a second page?
  19. WCF Error “Maximum number of items that can be serialized or deserialized in an object graph is ‘65536’”
  20. Best HashTag Regex
  21. Can I overlay a WPF window on top of another?
  22. How can I produce a “print preview” of a FlowDocument in a WPF application?
  23. WCF service startup error “This collection already contains an address with scheme http”
  24. How do I store a dictionary object in my web.config file?
  25. Passing quotes in Process.Start arguments
  26. No AppDomains in .NET Core! Why?
  27. How to test a WPF user interface?
  28. Regex to match anything but two words
  29. Standard Windows menu bars in Windows Forms
  30. What’s the purpose of the Tuple(T1)/Singleton in .net?

Leave a Comment