Why doesn’t a missing annotation cause a ClassNotFoundException at runtime?

by

In the earlier public drafts for JSR-175 (annotations), it was discussed if the compiler and runtime should ignore unknown annotations, to provide a looser coupling between the usage and declaration of annotations. A specific example was the use of applications server specific annotations on an EJB to control the deployment configuration. If the same bean should be deployed on a different application server, it would have been convenient if the runtime simply ignored the unknown annotations instead of raising a NoClassDefFoundError.

Even if the wording is a little bit vague, I assume that the behaviour you are seeing is specified in JLS 13.5.7: “… removing annotations has no effect on the correct linkage of the binary representations of programs in the Java programming language.” I interpret this as if annotations are removed (not available at runtime), the program should still link and run and that this implies that the unknown annotations are simply ignored when accessed through reflection.

The first release of Sun’s JDK 5 did not implement this correctly, but it was fixed in 1.5.0_06. You can find the relevant bug 6322301 in the bug database, but it does not point to any specifications except claiming that “according to the JSR-175 spec lead, unknown annotations must be ignored by getAnnotations”.

More Related Contents:

  1. Only one annotation is showing
  2. When do you use Java’s @Override annotation and why?
  3. Do I need elements in persistence.xml?
  4. Emulate annotation inheritance for interfaces and methods with AspectJ
  5. How and where are Annotations used in Java?
  6. Why does Eclipse complain about @Override on interface methods?
  7. Get rid of “The value for annotation attribute must be a constant expression” message [duplicate]
  8. Is there something like Annotation Inheritance in java?
  9. Retrieve Java Annotation Attribute
  10. can someone please explain me @MapsId in hibernate?
  11. How can I reload properties file in Spring 4 using annotations?
  12. How to scan multiple paths using the @ComponentScan annotation?
  13. How to supply Enum value to an annotation from a Constant in Java
  14. Error setting a default null value for an annotation’s field
  15. intellij incorrectly saying no beans of type found for autowired repository
  16. How to find annotated methods in a given package?
  17. Annotating the functional interface of a Lambda Expression
  18. Where should I put @Transactional annotation: at an interface definition or at an implementing class?
  19. Inherited abstract class with JPA (+Hibernate)
  20. Multiple annotations of the same type on one element?
  21. org.hibernate.MappingException: Could not determine type for: java.util.Set [duplicate]
  22. Accessing source code from Java Annotation Processor
  23. What is the default annotation processors discovery process?
  24. Name attribute in @Entity and @Table
  25. Spring MVC: difference between and tags? [duplicate]
  26. Why should anybody put annotations on the getters or setters when using JPA to map the classes?
  27. In Java why this error: ‘attribute value must be constant’?
  28. ElementType.LOCAL_VARIABLE annotation type
  29. how to make a composite primary key (java persistence annotation)
  30. How to disable TestNG test based on a condition

Leave a Comment