Why doesn’t java.lang.Number implement Comparable? [duplicate]

by

It’s worth mentioning that the following expression:

new Long(10).equals(new Integer(10))

is always false, which tends to trip everyone up at some point or another. So not only can you not compare arbitrary Numbers but you can’t even determine if they’re equal or not.

Also, with the real primitive types (float, double), determining if two values are equal is tricky and has to be done within an acceptable margin of error. Try code like:

double d1 = 1.0d;
double d2 = 0.0d;
for (int i=0; i<10; i++) {
  d2 += 0.1d;
}
System.out.println(d2 - d1);

and you’ll be left with some small difference.

So back to the issue of making Number Comparable. How would you implement it? Using something like doubleValue() wouldn’t do it reliably. Remember the Number subtypes are:

  • Byte;
  • Short;
  • Integer;
  • Long;
  • AtomicInteger;
  • AtomicLong;
  • Float;
  • Double;
  • BigInteger; and
  • BigDecimal.

Could you code a reliable compareTo() method that doesn’t devolve into a series of if instanceof statements? Number instances only have six methods available to them:

  • byteValue();
  • shortValue();
  • intValue();
  • longValue();
  • floatValue(); and
  • doubleValue().

So I guess Sun made the (reasonable) decision that Numbers were only Comparable to instances of themselves.

More Related Contents:

  1. What is the internal sorting technique used in comparator and comparable interfaces and why? [duplicate]
  2. Sorting Java objects using multiple keys
  3. How do I make 2 comparable methods in only one class?
  4. Java Sorting: sort an array of objects by property, object not allowed to use Comparable
  5. Java sort 4 arrays into 1 array
  6. In selection sort, if we have two duplicate elements, what is the behavior of the algorithm?
  7. Sorted array in Java: how can I implement? [closed]
  8. Sort on a string that may contain a number
  9. Why is there no SortedList in Java?
  10. How to sort List of objects by some property
  11. Java Array Sort descending?
  12. Java Set retain order?
  13. Java 8 stream reverse order
  14. How do I sort a list by different parameters at different timed
  15. How to sort Date which is in string format in java?
  16. Why does my sorting loop seem to append an element where it shouldn’t?
  17. Sorting Strings that contains number in Java [duplicate]
  18. Java List Sorting: Is there a way to keep a list permantly sorted automatically like TreeMap?
  19. Is it faster to add to a collection then sort it, or add to a sorted collection?
  20. Sort List in reverse in order
  21. Android how to sort JSONArray of JSONObjects
  22. sorting integers in order lowest to highest java
  23. Why does my JTable sort an integer column incorrectly?
  24. How to use Collections.sort() in Java?
  25. Using a prepared statement and variable bind Order By in Java with JDBC driver
  26. Sort List of Strings with Localization
  27. sorting a List of Map
  28. Sorting ArrayList of Objects by Object attribute
  29. Check if an array is sorted, return true or false
  30. How to sort Alphanumeric String

Leave a Comment