Why include guards do not prevent multiple function definitions? [duplicate]

by

“1) Why do the include guards not prevent multiple definitions of this function like they do for other header items”

Because each translation unit (i.e. .cpp file) is processed separately and goes through the same conditional. Translation units won’t share the preprocessor definitions encountered by other translation units. This means that all the translation units that will process that header will include a definition for that function. Of course, the linker will then complain that the same function has multiple definitions.

“2) Why does the static word resolve this when static is supposed to prevent names from visibility in other translation units?”

Because the static keyword makes a private copy of that function for each translation unit.

If you want that function to be defined in a shared header, however, you should rather mark it as inline, which will solve your problem and will make the preprocessor guards unnecessary.

More Related Contents:

  1. Is const_cast safe?
  2. C++ deprecated conversion from string constant to ‘char*’
  3. Why does omission of “#include ” only sometimes cause compilation failures?
  4. strptime() equivalent on Windows?
  5. Is it safe to use -1 to set all bits to true?
  6. Why does C++ allow us to surround the variable name in parentheses when declaring a variable?
  7. vector size – 1 when size is 0 in C++
  8. Are variable length arrays there in c++?
  9. __builtin_prefetch, How much does it read?
  10. How do you create a static class in C++?
  11. When should I use raw pointers over smart pointers?
  12. Retrieving file descriptor from a std::fstream [duplicate]
  13. How to atomically update a maximum value?
  14. How do I tell if the c function atoi failed or if it was a string of zeros?
  15. Can std::launder be used to convert an object pointer to its enclosing array pointer?
  16. C++: overriding public\private inheritance
  17. How can I avoid including class implementation files?
  18. Creating a new C++ Project in Eclipse CDT with the same settings as another project
  19. Template typedefs – What’s your work around?
  20. Are there in x86 any instructions to accelerate SHA (SHA1/2/256/512) encoding?
  21. Call destructor and then constructor (resetting an object)
  22. STL deque accessing by index is O(1)?
  23. How to read huge file in c++
  24. Is MAXIMUM_WAIT_OBJECTS really 64?
  25. Convert inline assembly code to C++
  26. namespaces for enum types – best practices
  27. templated typedef?
  28. How to create class objects dynamically?
  29. Will consteval allow using static_assert on function arguments?
  30. What happens if main() does not return an int value?

Leave a Comment