Why is `self` in Python objects immutable?

by

Any simple assignment to any argument of any function behaves exactly the same way in Python: binds that name to a different value, and does nothing else whatsoever. “No special case is special enough to break the rules”, as the Zen of Python says!-)

So, far from it being odd (that simply=assigning to a specific argument in a specific function has no externally visible effect whatsoever), it would be utterly astonishing if this specific case worked in any other way, just because of the names of the function and argument in question.

Should you ever want to make a class that constructs an object of a different type than itself, such behavior is of course quite possible — but it’s obtained by overriding the special method __new__, not __init__:

class Test(object):
    def __new__(cls):
        return 5

t = Test()
print t

This does emit 5. The __new__ / __init__ behavior in Python is an example of the “two-step construction” design pattern: the “constructor” proper is __new__ (it builds and returns a (normally uninitialized) object (normally a new one of the type/class in question); __init__ is the “initializer” which properly initializes the new object.

This allows, for example, the construction of objects that are immutable once constructed: in this case everything must be done in __new__, before the immutable object is constructed, since, given that the object is immutable, __init__ cannot mutate it in order to initialize it.

More Related Contents:

  1. Calling a function of a module by using its name (a string)
  2. How to access object attribute given string corresponding to name of that attribute
  3. How to print instances of a class using print()?
  4. Spawning multiple instances of the same object concurrently in python
  5. How do I call a parent class’s method from a child class in Python?
  6. Convert nested Python dict to object?
  7. Is everything an object in Python like Ruby?
  8. super() fails with error: TypeError “argument 1 must be type, not classobj” when parent does not inherit from object
  9. Python dictionary from an object’s fields
  10. How can I separate the functions of a class into multiple files?
  11. Using self.xxxx as a default parameter – Python
  12. How do I save and restore multiple variables in python?
  13. python assign values to list elements in loop
  14. Why is `object` an instance of `type` and `type` an instance of `object`?
  15. Why do I get a TypeError that says “takes no arguments (1 given)”? [duplicate]
  16. Why is the cmp parameter removed from sort/sorted in Python3.0?
  17. What does object’s __init__() method do in python? [duplicate]
  18. Null object in Python
  19. How to check if an object has an attribute in Python?
  20. How can I create an object and add attributes to it?
  21. How to check if an object has an attribute?
  22. How do I check if an object has an attribute?
  23. Saving and loading objects and using pickle
  24. Why do ints require three times as much memory in Python?
  25. How to make a copy of a 2D array in Python? [duplicate]
  26. “Enabling” comparison for classes [duplicate]
  27. What’s the difference between the square bracket and dot notations in Python?
  28. In Python, when are two objects the same?
  29. TypeError: Missing one required positional argument [duplicate]
  30. How can two Python objects have same id but ‘is’ operator returns False?

Leave a Comment