Why is the terminology of labels and levels in factors so weird?

by

I think the way to think about the difference between labels and levels (ignoring the labels() function that Tommy describes in his answer) is that levels is intended to tell R which values to look for in the input (x) and what order to use in the levels of the resulting factor object, and labels is to change the values of the levels after the input has been coded as a factor … as suggested by Tommy’s answer, there is no part of the factor object returned by factor() that is called labels … just the levels, which have been adjusted by the labels argument … (clear as mud).

For example:

> f <- factor(x=c("a","b","c"),levels=c("c","d","e"))
> f
[1] <NA> <NA> c  
Levels: c d e
> str(f)
Factor w/ 3 levels "c","d","e": NA NA 1

Because the first two elements of x were not found in levels, the first two elements of f are NA. Because "d" and "e" were included in levels, they show up in the levels of f even though they did not occur in x.

Now with labels:

> f <- factor(c("a","b","c"),levels=c("c","d","e"),labels=c("C","D","E"))
> f
[1] <NA> <NA> C   
Levels: C D E

After R figures out what should be in the factor, it re-codes the levels. One can of course use this to do brain-frying things such as:

> f <- factor(c("a","b","c"),levels=c("c","d","e"),labels=c("a","b","c"))
> f
[1] <NA> <NA> a   
Levels: a b c

Another way to think about levels is that factor(x,levels=L1,labels=L2) is equivalent to

f <- factor(x,levels=L1)
levels(f) <- L2

I think an appropriately phrased version of this example might be nice for Pat Burns’s R inferno — there are plenty of factor puzzles in section 8.2, but not this particular one …

More Related Contents:

  1. Reorder levels of a factor without changing order of values
  2. `levels
  3. ggplot2 keep unused levels barplot
  4. Find the most frequent value by row
  5. Re-ordering factor levels in data frame [duplicate]
  6. Keep unused levels in bar plot
  7. How can I drop unused levels from a data frame?
  8. Remove unused factor levels from a ggplot bar plot
  9. Naming columns in a data table in R
  10. Split data frame string column into multiple columns
  11. How do I arrange a variable list of plots using grid.arrange?
  12. Selecting only numeric columns from a data frame
  13. Use of ~ (tilde) in R programming Language
  14. Conditional merge/replacement in R
  15. ggplot2 pie and donut chart on same plot
  16. Count number of rows matching a criteria
  17. R: += (plus equals) and ++ (plus plus) equivalent from c++/c#/java, etc.?
  18. Fast Levenshtein distance in R?
  19. lme4::lmer reports “fixed-effect model matrix is rank deficient”, do I need a fix and how to?
  20. Merge or combine by rownames
  21. R: How to get the Week number of the month
  22. How to get the cumulative sum by group in R?
  23. Combining new lines and italics in facet labels with ggplot2
  24. Rowwise cumulative sum
  25. Maps, ggplot2, fill by state is missing certain areas on the map
  26. remove kernel on jupyter notebook
  27. How to pass “nothing” as an argument to `[` for subsetting?
  28. Configuring compilers on Apple silicon (Big Sur, Monterey, Ventura) for Rcpp and other tools
  29. Creating a vertical color gradient for a geom_bar plot
  30. Divide each value by the sum of values by group

Leave a Comment