Why is there a `null` value in JavaScript?

by

The question isn’t really “why is there a null value in JS” – there is a null value of some sort in most languages and it is generally considered very useful.

The question is, “why is there an undefined value in JS”. Major places where it is used:

  1. when you declare var x; but don’t assign to it, x holds undefined;
  2. when your function gets fewer arguments than it declares;
  3. when you access a non-existent object property.

null would certainly have worked just as well for (1) and (2)*. (3) should really throw an exception straight away, and the fact that it doesn’t, instead of returning this weird undefined that will fail later, is a big source of debugging difficulty.

*: you could also argue that (2) should throw an exception, but then you’d have to provide a better, more explicit mechanism for default/variable arguments.

However JavaScript didn’t originally have exceptions, or any way to ask an object if it had a member under a certain name – the only way was (and sometimes still is) to access the member and see what you get. Given that null already had a purpose and you might well want to set a member to it, a different out-of-band value was required. So we have undefined, it’s problematic as you point out, and it’s another great JavaScript ‘feature’ we’ll never be able to get rid of.

I actually use undefined when I want to unset the values of properties no longer in use but which I don’t want to delete. Should I use null instead?

Yes. Keep undefined as a special value for signaling when other languages might throw an exception instead.

null is generally better, except on some IE DOM interfaces where setting something to null can give you an error. Often in this case setting to the empty string tends to work.

More Related Contents:

  1. Is there a standard function to check for null, undefined, or blank variables in JavaScript?
  2. What is the difference between null and undefined in JavaScript?
  3. How can I determine if a variable is ‘undefined’ or ‘null’?
  4. Why is null an object and what’s the difference between null and undefined?
  5. How to check for an undefined or null variable in JavaScript?
  6. JavaScript checking for null vs. undefined and difference between == and ===
  7. How to resolve TypeError: Cannot convert undefined or null to object
  8. What reason is there to use null instead of undefined in JavaScript?
  9. JavaScript String concatenation behavior with null or undefined values
  10. When is null or undefined used in JavaScript? [duplicate]
  11. Is it better to return `undefined` or `null` from a javascript function? [closed]
  12. Should JSON include null values [closed]
  13. Detecting an undefined object property
  14. How does “this” keyword work within a function?
  15. How can I unset a JavaScript variable?
  16. Are there legitimate uses for JavaScript’s “with” statement?
  17. JavaScript hashmap equivalent
  18. variable === undefined vs. typeof variable === “undefined”
  19. How do I check for null values in JavaScript?
  20. Why does this JavaScript code print “undefined” on the console?
  21. Why `null >= 0 && null
  22. forEach on array of undefined created by Array constructor
  23. JavaScript “cannot read property “bar” of undefined [duplicate]
  24. How do I check for an empty/undefined/null string in JavaScript?
  25. this is undefined inside arrow function
  26. Undefined return value from the function call Javascritpt
  27. console.log(myFunction()) returns undefined
  28. JS checking deep object property existence [duplicate]
  29. Can I set variables to undefined or pass undefined as an argument?
  30. JSLint: was used before it was defined

Leave a Comment