Android BLE BluetoothGatt.writeDescriptor() return sometimes false

by

The documentation lacks information. However you can read the source code to find out the rules, which (currently) are the following:

For each BluetoothGatt object, you can only have one outstanding request at a time, including requestMtu, readCharacteristic, writeCharacteristic, readDescriptor, writeDescriptor and executeReliableWrite. So if you issue a read request you need to wait for the read response before you issue a write request. While they implemented the code that returns false if there is an ongoing operation in BluetoothGatt.java, they forgot to do this for requestMtu, so if you have multiple requests at a time where requestMtu is one of them, you will get random errors sooner or later (in the latest versions at the time of this post).

So yes, every developer has to manually serialize the requests. Note that the Bluetooth stack actually has a queue of requests, but it is limited to only one request per client (i.e. BluetoothGatt object). So if two apps on the same phone talk to the same device simultaneously you will never get “busy” errors. The only exception is if you use Write Without Response for which the current data flow implementation is quite buggy (see https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/37121017 which Google seems to have ignored).

You can send notifications at the same time as you write a characteristic, since the server and client roles are separated.

Regarding updating the documentation, you can always try to file an issue at https://issuetracker.google.com (but I get the feeling nobody reads that), or, since Android is open source, send a pull request to https://android-review.googlesource.com/ which updates the Javadoc from which the documentation is generated.

More Related Contents:

  1. Android 4.3 Bluetooth Low Energy unstable
  2. Bluetooth Low Energy startScan on Android 6.0 does not find devices
  3. Location needs to be enabled for Bluetooth Low Energy Scanning on Android 6.0
  4. How to programmatically force bluetooth low energy service discovery on Android without using cache
  5. GATT callback fails to register
  6. Should one create a bond with a Bluetooth LE device
  7. Android 4.3: How to connect to multiple Bluetooth Low Energy devices
  8. Android BLE API: GATT Notification not received
  9. Estimating beacon proximity/distance based on RSSI – Bluetooth LE
  10. How to get the battery level after connect to the BLE device?
  11. Find all Bluetooth devices (headsets, phones etc) nearby, without forcing the devices in discoverable mode
  12. Which correct flag of autoConnect in connectGatt of BLE?
  13. Can an Android device act as an iBeacon?
  14. Is the native Android BLE implementation synchronous in nature?
  15. Android: BLE how to read multiple Characteristics?
  16. Does BluetoothLeAdvertiser work on a Nexus 5 with Android 5.0?
  17. How many devices we can pair via Bluetooth of BLE to Android?
  18. Android : Permissions check for BLE [closed]
  19. BLE scan is not working when screen is off on Android 8.1.0
  20. How can I retrieve data from Firebase to my adapter
  21. What’s the difference between the various methods to get an Android Context?
  22. Location of sqlite database on the device
  23. How to change language of app when user selects language?
  24. How can I debug javascript on Android?
  25. Android – zoom in/out RelativeLayout with spread/pinch
  26. Android Manifest Restrict To Tablets
  27. Is there a way to have 1 Firebase database for 2 apps with different package names?
  28. How to make my layout able to scroll down?
  29. Margins of a LinearLayout, programmatically with dp
  30. android schedule task to execute at specific time daily

Leave a Comment