Are global static classes and methods bad?

by

Global data is bad. However many issues can be avoided by working with static methods.

I’m going to take the position of Rich Hickey on this one and explain it like this:

To build the most reliable systems in C# use static methods and classes, but not global data. For instance if you hand in a data object into a static method, and that static method does not access any static data, then you can be assured that given that input data the output of the function will always be the same. This is the position taken by Erlang, Lisp, Clojure, and every other Functional Programming language.

Using static methods can greatly simplify multi-threaded coding, since, if programmed correctly, only one thread will have access to a given set of data at a time. And that is really what it comes down to. Having global data is bad since it is a state that can be changed by who knows what thread, and any time. Static methods however allow for very clean code that can be tested in smaller increments.

I know this will be hotly debated, as it flies in the face of C#’s OOP thought process, but I have found that the more static methods I use, the cleaner and more reliable my code is.

This video explains it better than I can, but shows how immutable data, and static methods can produce some extremely thread-safe code.

Let me clarify a bit more some issues with Global Data. Constant (or read-only) global data isn’t nearly as big of an issue as mutable (read/write) global data. Therefore if it makes sense to have a global cache of data, use global data! To some extent every application that uses a database will have that, since we could say that all a SQL Database is one massive global variable that holds data.

So making a blanket statement like I did above is probably a bit strong. Instead, let’s say that having global data introduces many issues that can be avoid by having local data instead.

Some languages such as Erlang get around this issue by having the cache in a separate thread that handles all requests for that data. This way you know that all requests and modifications to that data will be atomic and the global cache will not be left in some unknown state.

More Related Contents:

  1. Why not inherit from List?
  2. IOException: The process cannot access the file ‘file path’ because it is being used by another process
  3. Is there an alternative to bastard injection? (AKA poor man’s injection via default constructor)
  4. What is the difference between the override and new keywords in C#?
  5. Static and Instance methods with the same name?
  6. Covariance and Contravariance with C# Arrays [duplicate]
  7. Is there a much better way to create deep and shallow clones in C#?
  8. Can you explain Liskov Substitution Principle with a good C# example? [closed]
  9. Compilation Error: “The modifier ‘public’ is not valid for this item” while explicitly implementing the interface
  10. Why is processing a sorted array slower than an unsorted array?
  11. Why does this polymorphic C# code print what it does?
  12. Using Reflection to create a DataTable from a Class?
  13. Method Overloading with different return type [duplicate]
  14. Why do both the abstract class and interface exist in C#?
  15. Field initialization
  16. How can I use escape characters with string interpolation in C# 6?
  17. CryptographicException “Key not valid for use in specified state.” while trying to export RSAParameters of a X509 private key
  18. Process.Start(url) fails
  19. The type ‘System.IDisposable’ is defined in an assembly that is not referenced
  20. How can I convert a DataTable to an XML file in C#?
  21. How to get all children of a parent control?
  22. Autocomplete combobox for WPF
  23. IDENTITY INSERT and LINQ to SQL
  24. Is it safe to test the X509Certificate.Thumbprint property when you know an invalid certificate is safe?
  25. Why are WinForms applications STAThread by default?
  26. How to add smtp hotmail account to send mail
  27. How to follow the end of a text in a TextBox with no NoWrap?
  28. How to use LogonUser properly to impersonate domain user from workgroup client
  29. How do I make a form modal in Windows Forms?
  30. generic NOT constraint where T : !IEnumerable

Leave a Comment