Are Lambda expressions in C# closures?

by

A lambda may be implemented using a closure, but it is not itself necessarily a closure.

A closure is “a function together with a referencing environment for the non-local variables of that function.”.

When you make a lambda expression that uses variables defined outside of the method, then the lambda must be implemented using a closure. For example:

int i = 42;

Action lambda = () => { Console.WriteLine(i); };

In this case, the compiler generated method must have access to the variable (i) defined in a completely different scope. In order for this to work, the method it generates is a “function together with the referencing environment” – basically, it’s creating a “closure” to retrieve access to the variable.

However, this lambda:

Action lambda2 = () => { Console.WriteLine("Foo"); }

does not rely on any “referencing environment”, since it’s a fully contained method. In this case, the compiler generates a normal static method, and there is no closure involved at all.

In both cases, the lambda is creating a delegate (“function object”), but it’s only creating a closure in the first case, as the lambda doesn’t necessarily need to “capture” the referencing environment in all cases.

More Related Contents:

  1. System.Linq.Expression.Compile error
  2. Join/Where with LINQ and Lambda
  3. Why is it bad to use an iteration variable in a lambda expression
  4. delegate keyword vs. lambda notation
  5. How to perform Join between multiple tables in LINQ lambda
  6. Using the iterator variable of foreach loop in a lambda expression – why fails?
  7. Lambda variable capture in loop – what happens here? [duplicate]
  8. Weak event handler model for use with lambdas
  9. Get the property, as a string, from an Expression
  10. Multiple Order By with LINQ [duplicate]
  11. What are C# lambda’s compiled into? A stackframe, an instance of an anonymous type, or?
  12. What’s the point of a lambda expression?
  13. C# => operator?
  14. “Nested foreach” vs “lambda/linq query” performance(LINQ-to-Objects) [closed]
  15. Entity Framework – Cannot convert lambda expression to type ‘string’ because it is not a delegate type
  16. Cannot use a lambda expression as an argument to a dynamically dispatched operation without first casting it to a delegate or expression tree type
  17. LINQ – Query syntax vs method chains & lambda [closed]
  18. Can a C# lambda expression have more than one statement?
  19. How to check for nulls in a deep lambda expression? [duplicate]
  20. String.IsNullOrWhiteSpace in LINQ Expression
  21. What does “DisplayClass” name mean when calling lambda?
  22. MVC HTML Helpers and Lambda Expressions
  23. How do I create an expression tree for run time sorting?
  24. Is there a way to specify an “empty” C# lambda expression?
  25. Is there a better way to express a parameterless lambda than () =>?
  26. Lambda Expression for join
  27. Getting names of local variables (and parameters) at run-time through lambda expressions
  28. Declaring Func dynamically
  29. ‘Delegate ‘System.Action’ does not take 0 arguments.’ Is this a C# compiler bug (lambdas + two projects)?
  30. How to convert Func to Predicate?

Leave a Comment