Are non-capturing groups redundant?

by

Your (?:wo)?men and (wo)?men are semantically equivalent, but technically are different, namely, the first is using a non-capturing and the other a capturing group. Thus, the question is why use non-capturing groups when we have capturing ones?

Non-caprturing groups are of help sometimes.

  1. To avoid excessive number of backreferences (remember that it is sometimes difficult to use backreferences higher than 9)
  2. To avoid the problem with 99 numbered backreferences limit (by reducing the number of numbered capturing groups) (source: Regular-expressions.info: Most regex flavors support up to 99 capturing groups and double-digit backreferences.)
    NOTE this does not pertain to Java regex engine, nor to PHP or .NET regex engines.
  3. To lessen the overhead caused by storing the captures in the stack
  4. We can add more groupings to existing regex without ruining the order of capturing groups.

Also, it is just makes our matches cleaner:

You can use a non-capturing group to retain the organisational or grouping benefits but without the overhead of capturing.

It does not seem a good idea to re-factor existing regular expressions to convert capturing to non-capturing groups, since it may ruin the code or require too much effort.

More Related Contents:

  1. Java Variable Substitution
  2. Regex to match end-of-sentence markers [closed]
  3. Java regular expression “( *|)”: what does the pipe do? [duplicate]
  4. Want to extract values from text file using regex
  5. Java regex email
  6. How to split a string between letters and digits (or between digits and letters)?
  7. How to split a string, but also keep the delimiters?
  8. How can non-ASCII characters be removed from a string?
  9. Regex look-behind without obvious maximum length in Java
  10. Returning overlapping regular expressions
  11. A regex to match a substring that isn’t followed by a certain other substring
  12. Java; String replace (using regular expressions)?
  13. Java regular expressions and dollar sign
  14. Java: Split string when an uppercase letter is found
  15. Java Regex to Validate Full Name allow only Spaces and Letters
  16. How to escape comma and double quote at same time for CSV file?
  17. Simple Java regex matcher not working
  18. removing characters of a specific unicode range from a string
  19. Can you use zero-width matching regex in String split?
  20. Use Java and RegEx to convert casing in a string
  21. RegEx in Java: how to deal with newline
  22. Set minimum and maximum characters in a regular expression
  23. Pattern to extract text between parenthesis
  24. What are the differences between perl and java regex capabilities?
  25. Java Regex Illegal Escape Character in Character Class
  26. Regex search with pattern containing (?:.|\s)*? takes increasingly long time
  27. Java regex error – Look-behind group does not have an obvious maximum length
  28. Parse Date from String in this format : dd/MM/yyyy [to dd/MM/yyyy]
  29. How can I perform a partial match with java.util.regex.*?
  30. Java replace all square brackets in a string

Leave a Comment